# The Council Tax Reduction Schemes (Detection of Fraud and Enforcement) (England) Regulations 2013, Regulation 11: Penalty as alternative to prosecution


(1) This regulation applies where a person’s (P) liability to pay council tax in respect of a chargeable dwelling and one or more financial years (or part of a financial year) has been reduced under a council tax reduction scheme, and it appears to a billing authority that—
(a) the amount by which P’s liability to pay council tax was reduced under the scheme is greater than the amount of the reduction to which P was entitled under the scheme (an “excess reduction”);
(b) the award of the excess reduction was attributable to an act or omission on the part of P; and
(c) there are grounds for instituting proceedings against P for an offence (under these Regulations or any other enactment) relating to the award of the excess reduction.
(2) This regulation also applies where it appears to a billing authority that—
(a) there are grounds for instituting proceedings against a person (P) for an offence (under these Regulations or any other enactment) relating to an act or omission on the part of P in relation to a council tax reduction scheme; and
(b) the act or omission could have resulted in the amount of council tax P is liable to pay being reduced under a council tax reduction scheme by an amount greater than the amount of reduction to which P was entitled under the scheme.
(3) Where this regulation applies, the authority may give P a written notice stating that P may be invited to agree to pay a penalty and that, if P does so in the manner specified by the authority, no proceedings referred to in paragraphs (1) and (2) will be instituted against P.
(4) The amount of the penalty in a case falling within paragraph (1) is to be 50 per cent of the amount of the excess reduction (rounded down to the nearest whole penny), subject to—
(a) a minimum amount of £100; and
(b) a maximum amount of £1000.
(5) For the purpose of paragraph (4), the excess reduction is to be calculated on a daily basis beginning with the first day in respect of which the excess reduction was awarded and ending with the day on which the authority knew or ought reasonably to have known that an excess reduction had been awarded.
(6) The amount of the penalty in a case falling within paragraph (2) is £100.
(7) If P agrees in the specified manner to pay the penalty—
(a) the amount of the penalty shall be recoverable by the authority; and
(b) no proceedings will be instituted against P for an offence (under these Regulations or any other enactment) relating to the excess reduction referred to in paragraph (1) or to the act or omission referred to in paragraph (2).
(8) P may withdraw P’s agreement to pay the penalty by notifying the billing authority, in the manner specified by the authority, at any time during the period of 14 days beginning with the day on which P agrees to pay it; and if P does so—
(a) so much of the penalty as has already been recovered shall be repaid; and
(b) paragraph (7) shall not apply.
(9) In a case falling within paragraph (1) where, after P has agreed to pay the penalty, it is subsequently decided that an excess reduction has not been awarded, the penalty shall be quashed and so much of the penalty as has already been recovered shall be repaid.
(10) In a case falling within paragraph (1) where, after P has agreed to pay the penalty, the amount of the excess reduction is revised —
(a) so much of the penalty as has already been recovered shall be repaid; and
(b) paragraph (7) shall no longer apply by reason of the agreement,
but if a new agreement is made under this regulation in relation to the revised excess reduction, the amount already recovered by way of penalty, to the extent that it does not exceed the amount of the new penalty, may be treated as recovered under the new agreement instead of being repaid.
(11) The notice referred to in paragraph (3) must contain information—
(a) in a case falling within paragraph (1), that the penalty only applies to the award of a reduction under the billing authority’s council tax reduction scheme greater than the amount to which the person was entitled under the scheme;
(b) in a case falling within paragraph (1), that the penalty only applies where it appears to the billing authority that the award of the excess reduction was attributable to an act or omission by the person and that there are grounds for instituting proceedings for an offence relating to the award of the excess reduction;
(c) in a case falling within paragraph (2), that the penalty only applies where it appears to the billing authority that—
(i) there are grounds for instituting proceedings against the person for an offence relating to an act or omission on the part of that person in relation to a council tax reduction scheme; and
(ii) the act or omission could have resulted in the amount of council tax the person is liable to pay being reduced under a council tax reduction scheme by an amount greater than the amount of reduction to which the person was entitled under the scheme;
(d) in a case falling within paragraph (1), that the penalty is 50 per cent of the amount of the excess reduction (subject to the maximum and minimum amounts referred to in paragraph (4));
(e) in a case falling within paragraph (2), that the penalty is £100;
(f) in a case falling within paragraph (1), that the penalty is payable in addition to repayment of the excess reduction and the method by which the penalty is recoverable;
(g) in a case falling within paragraph (2), the method by which the penalty is recoverable;
(h) that a person who agrees to pay a penalty may withdraw the agreement within 14 days (including the date of the agreement) by notifying the billing authority in the manner specified by the billing authority; if the person withdraws the agreement, so much of the penalty as has already been recovered shall be repaid and that person will no longer be immune from proceedings for an offence;
(i) in a case falling within paragraph (1), that if it is subsequently decided that an excess reduction has not been awarded, so much of the penalty as has already been recovered shall be repaid;
(j) in a case falling within paragraph (1), that if the amount of the excess reduction is revised by the billing authority, except as covered by a new agreement to pay the revised penalty, so much of the penalty as has already been recovered shall be repaid and the person will no longer be immune from proceedings for an offence;
(k) that the payment of a penalty does not give the person immunity from prosecution in relation to any other award of an excess reduction, any offence not relating to an award of an excess reduction or (in a case falling within paragraph (2)) any other act or omission; and
(l) that, where a penalty is imposed on a person under this regulation, if the person alleges that there is no power in the case concerned to impose a penalty of the amount imposed, the person may appeal to a valuation tribunal under paragraph 3(4) of Schedule 3 to the 1992 Act against the imposition.
(12) The notice must set out—
(a) the manner specified by the billing authority by which the person may agree to pay a penalty; and
(b) the manner specified by the billing authority by which the person may notify the withdrawal of his or her agreement to pay a penalty.

---
Source: https://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukdsi/2013/9780111533154/regulation/11 (the official version)
Page: https://openlegislation.uk/draft-council-tax-reduction-schemes-detection-of-fraud-and-enforcement-england-regulations-2013/regulation-11
Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0. Source: legislation.gov.uk, The National Archives.

