OpenLegislation

Division 3.1.6.1 Peer review evaluation of frontier research projects

United Kingdom

Original text. Later amendments are not shown.

The peer review evaluation is carried out by means of Panels of independent scientists and scholars. Panels may be assisted by panel evaluators and specialist referees, who perform the peer review evaluation fully or partially at their home or place of work (‘remote evaluation’). Panels are established to span the spectrum of research areas covered by the call, each Panel having responsibility for a particular set of research fields.

Panels operate, according to the rules of procedure for ERC Panels mentioned above, under the chairmanship of a senior independent expert.

Any peer review evaluation may be organised in two subsequent steps. In such case, the outcome of the first step is the input for the second step. The sequence of events in a step is usually as follows:

Allocation of proposals to Panels
  • Each proposal is allocated to a Panel on the basis of the subject-matter of the proposal. Initial allocation will be based on indication provided by the applicant, the title and content of the proposal and/or information, possibly in the form of ‘keywords’, provided for in the proposal.

  • Individual assessment
  • Proposals are examined against the relevant criteria by at least 3 peer reviewersf1, qualified in the scientific and/or technological fields related to the proposal, who prepare individual assessment reports (IARs).

  • Panel assessment
  • Panels have the duty to examine consistently proposals falling within their area of competencef2 and to operate in a coherent manner with other Panels, to ensure consistency of treatment of proposals across the range of Panels and the scientific/technological areas open in the call.

    The judgement of a Panel on a proposal (including any scores given to the proposal for individual criteria or overall, and its position in the ranked list) is based on the individual assessments and discussion in the Panel, and is arrived at by majority vote. The outcome of the Panel assessment phase is a rank order list. In the final step of the peer review evaluation, the Panel identifies those proposals which are recommended for funding, according to the budget associated to the call.

  • Interviews
  • Where this is specified in the Ideas work programme, the Panel assessment may include interviews with the PI and/or the applicant legal entity. Travel and subsistence costs incurred in relation to interviews may be reimbursed by the ERCEA. The rules for reimbursement applicable to interviewees are specified in Annex C. Any interview will be conducted by at least three Panel members. Interviews may be conducted at the location of the peer review evaluation Panel meeting or, subject to technical feasibility, by electronic means (video link, teleconference or similar).

  • Cross-Panel Assessment (Assessment across Panels, domains, research fields, etc.)
  • The cross-Panel assessment establishes a final recommended rank order of proposals retained for the call as a whole (across all fields of research open in the call), through a careful assessment of the quality of proposals across the different Panels. This assessment is carried out in a forum constituted by the Panel chairs or their delegated Panel members. The cross-Panel assessment pays particular attention to proposals of an interdisciplinary nature which cross the boundaries between different Panels, proposals in new and emerging fields and ‘high-risk, high-gain’ proposals.

  • If the Ideas work programme sets indicative budgets associated with each Panel, domain, research field, etc., the discussion may consider only those proposals outside the set of proposals that are sufficiently highly ranked as to fall within the indicative budget set for each Panel, domain, research field, etc.

    The peer review evaluation results in an Evaluation Report (ER) for each proposal, including the results of a cross panel, where appropriate, stating the final recommendation of the panel on the proposal, along with the individual independent experts’ assessments, as well as any recommendation made on the maximum amount of funding to be awarded.

    Annotations

    Footnotes

    f1

    This may include members of Panels other than the Panel(s) to which the proposal is assigned or referees.

    f2

    This includes cross-panel or cross-domain interdisciplinary proposals which may be assigned for review to members of more than one Panel or additional referees.

    Notes on Division 3.1.6

    Footnotes

    f1

    In accordance with Article 16.1 of the Rules for Participation.