Division (a) Principles of experimental design
United Kingdom
Field trials used for the production of material for the comparative analysis shall be performed in order to determine whether the genetically modified plant and/or the genetically modified food and feed is different from its conventional counterpart and/or equivalent to non-genetically modified reference varieties with a history of safe use.
For each endpoint, the comparative analysis shall involve the following two approaches:
- (i)
a test of difference, to verify whether the genetically modified plant is different from its conventional counterpart and might therefore be considered a hazard depending on the type of the identified difference, and on the magnitude and type of exposure;
- (ii)
a test of equivalence to verify whether the genetically modified plant is equivalent or not to non-genetically modified reference varieties, apart from the introduced trait(s).
In testing for difference, the null hypothesis shall be that there is no difference between the GMO and its conventional counterpart against the alternative hypothesis that a difference exists.
Where additional comparator(s) are used for the risk assessment, a test of difference shall be carried out between the genetically modified plant and each of the additional comparator(s) following the requirements set out in Section 1.3.2.2 for the test of difference between the genetically modified plant and its conventional counterpart.
In testing for equivalence, the null hypothesis shall be that the difference between the GMO and the set of reference varieties is at least as great as a specified minimum size (see Section 1.3.2.2) against the alternative hypothesis that there is no difference or a smaller difference than the specified minimum between the GMO and the set of reference varieties.
Rejection of the null hypothesis shall be required in order to conclude that the GMO and the set of reference varieties are unambiguously equivalent for the endpoint considered. The equivalence limits used for the test of equivalence shall represent appropriately the range of natural variation expected for reference varieties with a history of safe use.