Paragraph 19 New rules 16A and 16B
After rule 16, insert—
“Powers of Medical Practitioners Tribunal in respect of failure to comply with Rules or directions
16A.(1)Paragraph (2) applies where, in a matter referred to the MPTS for them to arrange for consideration by a Medical Practitioners Tribunal under rule 17, 22 or 24 (as the case may be) on or after the relevant date, a party fails to comply with—
(a)these Rules, or
(b)a direction which was issued on or after that date by the Tribunal or the Case Manager.
For these purposes, the “relevant date” is the date this provision comes into force.
(2)Where there is a failure referred to in paragraph (1), a Medical Practitioners Tribunal may in respect of that failure—
(a)draw adverse inferences;
(b)refuse to admit evidence where the failure relates to the admissibility of that evidence; and
(c)award costs in accordance with rule 16B (a costs award).
Costs awards
16B.(1)A Medical Practitioners Tribunal may make a costs award under rule 16A(2)(c), following an application from either party or of its own initiative.
(2)A costs award is an order that one party or their representative (“the paying party”) pay the costs of the other party (“the receiving party”), where the paying party’s conduct of the proceedings has been unreasonable.
(3)Before making a costs award, a Medical Practitioners Tribunal shall receive any evidence and hear any submissions from the parties, in particular with regard to—
(a)any rule, tribunal or case manager direction with which it is claimed a party has failed to comply; and
(b)the conduct which it is claimed is unreasonable.
(4)Where a Medical Practitioners Tribunal makes a costs award, it shall announce its decision and give its reasons for it.
(5)Where a costs award is made, the amount of costs payable under it shall be assessed by a Case Manager after—
(a)the receiving party has, within a period of 28 days commencing with the conclusion of the proceedings in which the costs award was made, served a schedule of costs on both—
(i)the Case Manager, and
(ii)the paying party;
(b)the paying party has, within a period of 28 days commencing with receipt of the receiving party’s schedule of costs, served their response in writing to that schedule and evidence of their ability to pay on both—
(i)the Case Manager, and
(ii)the receiving party.
(6)Following receipt of the paying party’s response and evidence referred to in sub-paragraph (b) of paragraph (5), the Case Manager shall, having regard to the paying party’s ability to pay, make the assessment referred to in that paragraph. This is subject to paragraphs (7) and (8).
(7)Where the Case Manager considers it appropriate, he may—
(a)postpone the assessment referred to in paragraph (5);
(b)extend the period of 28 days referred to in sub-paragraph (a) or (b) (or as the case may be under both sub-paragraphs) of paragraph (5).
(8)The Case Manager may proceed with the assessment of the amount of costs payable regardless of any failure or delay by either party in serving their schedule of costs under sub-paragraph (a) of paragraph (5) or a response under sub-paragraph (b) of that paragraph.
(9)The MPTS shall serve notification of the Case Manager’s assessment of the amount of costs payable upon the parties.
(10)A costs award shall be enforced in the same manner as if the award had been made by order of the county court (or, in Scotland, by decree of the sheriff court, or in Northern Ireland, by order of a county court).
(11)Unless the Case Manager directs otherwise, the paying party under a costs award shall pay the costs assessed under it within 14 days of service upon that party of the Case Manager’s assessment of those costs.”.
Notes on Schedule
Footnotes
- f1
-
1983 c.54. Section 35CC was substituted by article 13 of S.I. 2002/3135 and amended by, paragraph 18 of Schedule 1 of S.I. 2008/3131 and article 22(1) of S.I. 2015/794. Paragraphs 19B to 19D, 23B and 24 of Schedule 1 were substituted by article 5(3) of S.I.2002/3135. Paragraph 19B was also amended by article 3(2) of S.I. 2006/1914.. Paragraph 19G of Schedule 1 was added by article 3(3) of S.I. 2015/794. Schedule 4 was substituted by S.I. 2002/3135. Paragraph 1(1) of Schedule 4 was amended by article 8(1) of S.I. 2015/794. S.I. 2015/794 added the following paragraphs to Schedule 4: paragraph 1(2ZA) was added by article 8(2); paragraphs 1(2ZB), (2B) to (2E) by article 9(1); paragraphs 1(3), (4) and (4B) to (4D) by article 8; paragraphs 5C(1) and (2) by article 11; paragraphs 5A(1), (2ZC) to (2ZE) by article 10; and 7A(6) and (9) by article 14 In making the Rules in the Schedule, the General Medical Council has given effect to the overriding objective in paragraph 1(1A) of Schedule 4 to the Medical Act 1983.