# The National Health Service (Service Committees and Tribunal) (Scotland) Regulations 1992, Regulation 11: Decision of Health Board


(1) A Health Board, after due consideration of a report submitted to them by a service committee by virtue of Schedule 1, shall—
(a) accept as conclusive the findings of fact made by the service committee;
(b) draw such inferences from those findings of fact as they see fit, having regard to such extent as they think fit to the service committee’s report as it relates to the inferences which may properly be drawn from those findings;
(c) determine whether the professional person to whom the report relates, where it is in relation to a complaint made in accordance with regulation 3 or a reference under regulation 8(1) which involves an allegation of a failure to comply with terms of service, has failed to comply with any one or more of his terms of service identified to him by the chairman of the service committee pursuant to paragraph 5(2) or 6(2) of Schedule 1; and
(d) determine—
(i) in the case of a complaint made in accordance with regulation 3 or a reference under regulation 8(1) which involves an allegation of a failure to comply with terms of service, the action to be taken in relation to the professional person concerned in accordance with either or both of paragraphs (2) and (4) having regard to any recommendation made by the service committee pursuant to paragraph 21(2) of Schedule 1;
(ii) in the case of a reference made under regulation 8(1) which does not involve an allegation of a failure to comply with terms of service, whether to take action in relation to the professional person concerned in accordance with paragraph (2); or
(iii) in any case to which the report of the service committee relates, that no further action shall be taken in relation to that report.
(2) Where, in the case of any doctor to whom a report of a service committee relates, a Health Board are satisfied—
(a) after consideration of the report in accordance with paragraph (1);
(b) whether or not they have found him to have failed to comply with his terms of service; and
(c) after consultation with the area medical committee,
that, because of the number of persons included in his list, the doctor is unable to give adequate treatment to all of those persons, they may impose a special limit on the number of persons for whom the doctor may undertake to provide treatment.
(3) Where, pursuant to paragraph (2), a Health Board impose a special limit on the number of patients for whom a doctor may undertake to provide treatment, paragraphs (4) to (8) of regulation 17 of the General Medical and Pharmaceutical Services Regulations (limitation of number of persons in doctors' lists) shall have effect in his case with suitable modifications and, in particular, as if references in those paragraphs—
(a) to a maximum number were references to the special limit imposed under paragraph (2) of this regulation; and
(b) to an excess were references to the extent to which the number of patients in the doctor’s list exceeds that special limit.
(4) Where they have determined that a professional person to whom the report of a service committee relates has failed to comply with any one or more of his terms of service, the Health Board concerned may—
(a) without prejudice to sub-paragraph (b), determine that there should be recovered from him, whether by way of a deduction from his remuneration or otherwise, any expenses (other than expenses incurred in connection with the investigation by the service committee) which, by reason of such failure, have been reasonably and necessarily incurred or, where the report relates to a dentist, are likely to be so incurred, by any person in obtaining further treatment, and that any such sums so recoverable shall be paid to that person;
(b) recommend to the Secretary of State that an amount should be recovered from the professional person concerned, whether by way of withholding from his remuneration or otherwise;
(c) where the professional person is a dentist, require the dentist until further notice to submit to the Scottish Dental Practice Board for prior approval estimates in respect of any description of treatment specified by that Board;
(d) determine that the professional person should be warned to comply with his terms of service in future;
(e) where they are of the opinion that the continued inclusion of the name of a profes sional person to whom the report of the service committee relates in the appropriate list of professional persons would be prejudicial to the efficiency of the category of services relevant to that list, make representations to that effect to the Tribunal.
(5) As soon as may be practicable after a Health Board have made their decision on the report of a service committee, the General Manager shall—
(a) send a copy of that report and the Health Board’s decision thereon and their reasons for it—
(i) in the case of a complaint made in accordance with regulation 3, to the complainer;
(ii) to the professional person concerned;
(iii) to the Secretary of State; and
(iv) if so requested by the complainer or the professional person concerned, to any patient concerned in the report, if that patient is not the complainer, and to any adviser to the complainer or professional person;
(b) where applicable, inform in writing the complainer or the professional person con cerned of his right of appeal to the Secretary of State under regulation 12 and of the power of the Secretary of State on such an appeal to award expenses.
(6) Any amount determined under paragraph (4)(a) as being recoverable shall—
(a) be a debt owing by the professional person concerned to the Health Board making the determination; and
(b) be recoverable from that professional person whether or not his name has, since—
(i) the event; or
(ii) where regulation 3(3)(b) or 8(4)(b) applies, the completion of the treatment,
which gave rise to the determination that he has failed to comply with his terms of service, ceased to be included in the relevant list of professional persons.
(7) Where a Health Board make a determination under paragraph (4)(a), no action shall be taken on that determination before—
(a) if no appeal is brought, the end of the period for bringing an appeal specified in regulation 12(2); or
(b) if an appeal is brought, they have received the notice of the Secretary of State’s decision of the appeal.

---
Source: https://www.legislation.gov.uk/uksi/1992/434/regulation/11 (the official version)
Page: https://openlegislation.uk/national-health-service-service-committees-and-tribunal-scotland-regulations-1992/regulation-11
Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0. Source: legislation.gov.uk, The National Archives.

