Regulation 30 Accelerated Misconduct Hearings
After Part 3 (misconduct hearings), insert—
“PART 3A
Accelerated Misconduct Hearings
General
24A.Any time period specified in this Part in relation to an accelerated misconduct hearing may be reduced by agreement between the Commissioner and the chairing member of the panel appointed in accordance with regulation 24H(2)(a).
Referral of case to accelerated misconduct hearing
24B.(1)Subject to paragraph (2), after receipt of the investigator’s report under regulation 14(1), the Commissioner may at any time determine whether the special conditions specified in paragraph (4) are satisfied.
(2)Where the case is referred to a misconduct hearing, the Commissioner must not make a determination under paragraph (1) on or after the date of the misconduct hearing.
(3)On receipt of a statement submitted by the investigator under regulation 14(4), the Commissioner must determine whether the special conditions are satisfied.
(4)The special conditions are that—
(a)there is sufficient evidence, in the form of written statements or other documents, to establish on the balance of probabilities that the conduct of the senior officer constitutes gross misconduct, and
(b)it is in the public interest for the senior officer to cease to hold office without delay.
(5)In a case where a misconduct hearing or an accelerated misconduct hearing has been suspended or postponed by virtue of regulation 7(1), as soon as practicable after—
(a)the appropriate prosecutor intimates to the Commissioner that criminal proceedings are not to be brought in respect of any matter mentioned in the misconduct allegation, or
(b)any criminal proceedings which have been brought have been concluded,
the Commissioner may make a determination, or in the case of an accelerated misconduct hearing must make a further determination, as to whether the special conditions are satisfied.
(6)Where the Commissioner determines that the special conditions are satisfied, unless the Commissioner considers that the circumstances are such as to make it inappropriate to do so, the Commissioner must certify the case as one where the special conditions are satisfied and refer it to an accelerated misconduct hearing.
(7)Where the Commissioner determines—
(a)that the special conditions are not satisfied, or
(b)that, although those conditions are satisfied, the circumstances are such as to make such certification inappropriate,
the Commissioner must, if the investigation was incomplete, return the case to the investigator to complete the investigation or, in any other case, proceed in accordance with regulation 15 and Part 3.
(8)Where the Commissioner is to proceed in accordance with regulation 15 and Part 3, regulation 15(1) must be read as if the words “Subject to regulation 24B, on receipt of the investigator’s report,” were omitted.
(9)In this regulation, “appropriate prosecutor” has the same meaning as in regulation 7.
Remission of case
24C.(1)At any time after the case has been referred to an accelerated misconduct hearing but before the beginning of that hearing, the Commissioner may direct that the case be dealt with in accordance with regulation 15 and Part 3 if the Commissioner considers that the special conditions are no longer satisfied.
(2)Where a direction is made under paragraph (1), the senior officer must be notified before the end of 4 working days beginning with the date on which that direction is made and the Commissioner must proceed in accordance with regulation 15 and Part 3.
(3)Where the Commissioner is to proceed in accordance with regulation 15 and Part 3, regulation 15(1) must be read as if the words “Subject to regulation 24B, on receipt of the investigator’s report,” were omitted.
Notice of referral to accelerated misconduct hearing
24D.(1)Where a case is certified under regulation 24B(6) as one where the special conditions are satisfied and referred to an accelerated misconduct hearing, the Commissioner must, unless paragraph (2) applies, as soon as practicable give the senior officer notice of these matters and must supply the senior officer with a copy of—
(a)the certificate issued under regulation 24B(6),
(b)any statement or written representations the senior officer may have made to the investigator during the course of the investigation,
(c)the investigator’s report (together with any document attached to or referred to in that report as relates to the senior officer), and
(d)any other relevant document obtained during the course of the investigation.
(2)This paragraph applies where the Commissioner considers that preventing the disclosure of any document mentioned in paragraph (1) is—
(a)necessary to avoid prejudicing current or future criminal proceedings,
(b)necessary for the purpose of the prevention or detection of crime or the apprehension or prosecution of offenders,
(c)necessary for the purpose of the prevention or detection of misconduct by other constables or police staff,
(d)necessary and proportionate for the protection of the welfare and safety of any informant or witness, or
(e)otherwise in the public interest.
(3)Where any document is withheld by virtue of the application of paragraph (2), the Commissioner must, so far as is reasonably possible without prejudicing any of the matters mentioned in that paragraph, provide the senior officer with a summary of the content of that document.
(4)The notice given under paragraph (1) must—
(a)describe the conduct that is the subject matter of the case and how that conduct is alleged to amount to gross misconduct,
(b)specify that the Commissioner will address the proceedings under regulation 24L(5),
(c)notify the senior officer of the effect of regulations 4 and 5,
(d)notify the senior officer of the right to seek advice from a staff association.
(5)For the purposes of paragraph (1), a notice is to be treated as having been given to the senior officer—
(a)if given to the senior officer in person, on the date on which it is given,
(b)if sent to the senior officer by email or by any other means of electronic communication, on the date on which it is sent,
(c)if left with a person at the senior officer’s last known address, on the date on which it is left,
(d)if sent to the senior officer’s last known address by first class post using a recorded delivery service or any other postal service which provides for recorded delivery the next working day, on the second working day after the date on which it is sent.
(6)Where a notice is required to be given to the senior officer under paragraph (1), it may instead be given to—
(a)a police representative chosen by the senior officer in accordance with regulation 4, or
(b)a legal representative acting for the senior officer in accordance with regulation 5,
and any such giving is to be treated for the purposes of this regulation (including paragraph (5)) as giving the notice to the senior officer.
Notice of accelerated misconduct hearing
24E.The chairing member of the panel appointed in accordance with regulation 24H(2)(a) must specify a date for the accelerated misconduct hearing which must be not less than 10 and not more than 15 working days after the date on which notice is given under regulation 24D(1) and must as soon as practicable—
(a)notify the senior officer of the date, time and place of that hearing, and
(b)notify the senior officer of the effect of regulations 4 and 5 in relation to an accelerated misconduct hearing,
(c)notify the senior officer of the names of the persons appointed to the panel in accordance with regulation 24H(1).
Public notification of accelerated misconduct hearing
24F.(1)The chairing member of the panel may require the Authority to give notice of the hearing which contains information relating to one or more of—
(a)the name of the senior officer,
(b)the date of the hearing,
(c)the time of the hearing,
(d)the place at which the hearing will take place, and
(e)the conduct that is the subject matter of the case and how that conduct is alleged to amount to gross misconduct, as set out in the notice given in accordance with regulation 24D(1).
(2)Where the chairing member of the panel requires notice to be given in accordance with paragraph (1), the Authority must publish the notice on its website as soon as practicable after notice of the hearing is given under regulation 24E(1).
(3)Any person to whom this paragraph applies may make written representations to the chairing member of the panel in relation to—
(a)whether, and if so the extent to which, the chairing member of the panel should exclude any person from the whole or part of the hearing under regulation 24K(2)(a),
(b)whether the chairing member of the panel should impose any conditions under regulation 24K(2)(b),
(c)whether the chairing member of the panel should give directions prohibiting the publication of any matter relating to the proceedings under regulation 24K(2)(c),
(d)in light of the representations made under sub-paragraphs (a) to (c)—
(i)whether the chairing member of the panel should require notice to be given under paragraph (1),
(ii)which types of information mentioned in paragraph (1)(a) to (e) should be included in any such notice.
(4)Paragraph (3) applies to—
(a)the senior officer,
(b)where the proceedings have arisen out of a complaint made by a member of the public, a constable, a member of the Authority’s staff or a member of police staff, the person who made the complaint, and
(c)the Commissioner.
(5)Any written representations made in accordance with paragraph (3) must be provided no later than the date specified by the chairing member of the panel for provision of such representations.
(6)The chairing member of the panel must notify each person listed in paragraph (4) of the date by which any written representations under paragraph (3) must be provided.
Procedure on receipt of notice
24G.(1)Before the end of 8 working days beginning with the date on which the senior officer is notified in accordance with regulation 24D(1), the senior officer must give the Commissioner and the chairing member of the panel—
(a)written notice of whether or not they accept that their conduct amounts to gross misconduct,
(b)where they accept that their conduct amounts to gross misconduct, any written submission they wish to make in mitigation,
(c)where they do not accept that their conduct amounts to gross misconduct, written notice of—
(i)the allegations they dispute and their account of the relevant events, and
(ii)any arguments on points of law they wish to be considered by the chairing member of the panel,
(d)a copy of any document they intend to rely on at the accelerated misconduct hearing.
(2)If the senior officer does not provide the written notice required under paragraph (1)(a) to (d), the Commissioner may refer the misconduct allegation to an accelerated misconduct hearing notwithstanding the senior officer’s failure to provide the written notice.
Appointment of panel
24H.(1)Where a case is—
(a)certified under regulation 24B(6) as one where the special conditions are satisfied, and
(b)referred to an accelerated misconduct hearing,
a panel of 3 individuals must be appointed to conduct the accelerated misconduct hearing.
(2)A panel under paragraph (1) must comprise—
(a)a chairing member, appointed by the Lord President from the legal members of the First-tier Tribunal, and
(b)two members appointed by the Authority—
(i)one member who is a senior expert in policing, and
(ii)one independent lay member, who the Authority considers has the appropriate skills, knowledge and expertise to serve on the panel.
(3)The senior expert in policing must not previously have worked directly with the senior officer.
(4)The chairing member of the panel must take appropriate action to ensure the efficient and effective bringing of proceedings and that they are conducted in a timely, fair and transparent manner.
(5)An individual appointed to serve on the panel must declare to the person appointing them any conflicts of interest which may arise from appointment to a panel.
(6)The Lord President, or the Authority, as appropriate, may not appoint to a panel—
(a)a member of the Authority,
(b)a member of the Authority’s staff,
(c)a member of any committee of the Authority established under paragraph 9(1) of schedule 1 of the Act,
(d)any individual whose appointment could give rise to a reasonable concern as to whether that individual could act impartially in relation to the misconduct hearing.
(7)The chairing member of the panel may appoint up to two individuals to act as assessors to assist the panel.
(8)An assessor appointed under paragraph (7) may provide the panel with such advice and assistance as the panel requests, but may not otherwise participate in the proceedings.
(9)Where a panel has been constituted under this regulation, a determination of the panel—
(a)is valid if made by a majority,
(b)must not disclose whether it was unanimous or by a majority.
(10)The Authority must pay panel members such remuneration and allowances as the Authority, with the approval of the Scottish Ministers, determines.
(11)In this regulation, “legal member” means an individual holding membership of the First-tier Tribunal in accordance with section 15(2) of the Tribunals (Scotland) Act 2014f1.
Documents to be supplied
24I.As soon as reasonably practicable prior to the accelerated misconduct hearing, the Commissioner must supply the chairing member of the panel with a copy of—
(a)the notice given to the senior officer under regulation 24D(1),
(b)the other documents given to the senior officer under regulation 24D(1), and
(c)the documents provided by the senior officer under regulation 24G(1).
Proceedings in senior officer’s absence
24J.(1)Where the senior officer informs the chairing member of the panel that the senior officer is unable to attend the accelerated misconduct hearing on grounds which the chairing member considers to be reasonable, including the senior officer’s welfare, the chairing member may permit the senior officer to participate in the proceedings by live television link or other suitable remote means.
(2)Paragraph (3) applies where the senior officer—
(a)participates in the accelerated misconduct hearing in accordance with paragraph (1), or
(b)otherwise does not attend that hearing.
(3)Where this paragraph applies—
(a)the senior officer may be represented at the accelerated misconduct hearing by the senior officer’s police representative, an advocate or a solicitor, and
(b)the hearing may proceed and conclude in the senior officer’s absence, whether or not the senior officer is so represented.
Reporting restrictions, participation and exclusions from accelerated misconduct hearing
24K.(1)Subject to paragraph (2), an accelerated misconduct hearing must be held in public.
(2)Having considered any representations received under regulation 24F(3), the chairing member of the panel may—
(a)in relation to the attendance at the hearing of a person under this regulation, exclude any person as they see fit from the whole or a part of it,
(b)impose such conditions as they see fit relating to the attendance of any person at the hearing in order to facilitate the proper conduct of it, and
(c)give such directions as they think appropriate prohibiting the publication of any matter relating to the hearing.
(3)Where it appears to the chairing member of the panel that any person may, in giving evidence, disclose information, being information to which paragraph (4) applies, which ought not to be disclosed to any person attending the proceedings (other than a party to the proceedings) the chairing member must require such attending persons to withdraw while the evidence is given.
(4)This paragraph applies to information insofar as the chairing member of the panel considers that preventing disclosure of it to an attendee is—
(a)necessary for the purpose of preventing the premature or inappropriate disclosure of information that is relevant to, or may be used in, any criminal proceedings,
(b)necessary for the purpose of the prevention or detection of crime, or the apprehension or prosecution of offenders,
(c)necessary for the purpose of the prevention or detection of misconduct by other constables or police staff,
(d)necessary and proportionate for the protection of the welfare and safety of any informant or witness, or
(e)otherwise in the public interest.
(5)Where the accelerated misconduct hearing has arisen from a complaint made by a member of the public, a constable, a member of the Authority’s staff or a member of police staff, the chairing member of the panel must notify the person who made the complaint of the date, time and location of that hearing.
Procedure at accelerated misconduct hearing
24L.(1)Subject to the following paragraphs of this regulation, the chairing member of the panel is to determine the procedure at the accelerated misconduct hearing.
(2)At the beginning of the accelerated misconduct hearing, the chairing member of the panel must give the senior officer the opportunity to say whether or not the senior officer accepts that the senior officer’s conduct amounts to gross misconduct.
(3)Subject to paragraph (4), no witnesses other than the senior officer may give evidence at the accelerated misconduct hearing and the chairing member of the panel must determine whether and by whom the senior officer can be questioned.
(4)The investigator, or suitable replacement with sufficient knowledge of the investigation to be able to answer questions, must attend the accelerated misconduct hearing at the request of the chairing member of the panel to answer questions.
(5)The Commissioner must address the proceedings for the purpose of—
(a)presenting the case against the senior officer,
(b)responding to any view expressed at the proceedings, and
(c)addressing the panel on any matter arising under these Regulations.
(6)Where the Commissioner is required to address the proceedings under paragraph (5), the Commissioner may be represented for that purpose by a solicitor or advocate.
(7)The senior officer, or their representative, may address the proceedings in order to—
(a)present the case of the senior officer,
(b)respond to any view expressed at the proceedings, and
(c)address the panel on any matter arising under these Regulations.
(8)An audio recording may be made of the accelerated misconduct hearing and, where such a recording is made, the senior officer must be provided with a copy of that recording as soon as reasonably practicable after the conclusion of the hearing.
(9)Where no audio recording is made under paragraph (8), a written record of the accelerated misconduct hearing must be prepared and—
(a)the chairing member of the panel must provide a draft of that record to the senior officer,
(b)the senior officer must be given the opportunity to make representations in relation to that draft,
(c)the chairing member of the panel must consider any representations made, and
(d)having considered those representations, if any, the chairing member of the panel must send the final written record of the accelerated misconduct hearing to the senior officer.
Determination and disciplinary action
24M.(1)At the conclusion of the accelerated misconduct hearing, the panel must—
(a)determine whether the conduct which is the subject matter of the misconduct allegation is the conduct of the senior officer,
(b)determine whether it is established that any conduct of the senior officer amounts to gross misconduct.
(2)A determination under paragraph (1) is to be made on the balance of probabilities.
(3)Where the panel has determined that the conduct of the senior officer does not amount to gross misconduct, the panel may—
(a)dismiss the case, or
(b)return the case to be dealt with in accordance with regulation 15 and Part 3.
(4)Where the panel has determined that the conduct of the senior officer amounts to gross misconduct, the panel must impose disciplinary action which, subject to the provisions of this regulation, may be—
(a)a final written warning,
(b)dismissal with such notice as the panel may specify, or
(c)dismissal without notice.
(5)Where, on the date of the determination under paragraph (1)(b), the senior officer was subject to a final written warning which was in effect, a final written warning may not be given.
(6)A final written warning remains in effect for a period of 2 years from the date on which it is given.
(7)Where a final written warning is given under paragraph (4)(a), the period in paragraph (6) may be extended by a panel conducting any subsequent accelerated misconduct hearing to a maximum period of 5 years.
Notification of outcome and publication
24N.(1)The chairing member of the panel must, as soon as reasonably practicable and not later than 10 working days from the date of conclusion of the accelerated misconduct hearing, submit a report to the Authority setting out—
(a)the determination of the panel under regulation 24M(1),
(b)the reasons for the determination,
(c)any disciplinary action imposed under regulation 24M(4), and
(d)where it was determined that the conduct of the senior officer amounted to gross misconduct but the disciplinary action imposed was not dismissal without notice, the reasons for that decision.
(2)Before the report is submitted to the Authority, the chairing member of the panel must, having regard to paragraph (4), consider, separately in relation to—
(a)submission to the Authority,
(b)disclosure to the senior officer,
(c)disclosure to any person under paragraph (7), and
(d)publication under paragraph (9),
whether any information contained in the report should be withheld, redacted or anonymised.
(3)Where the chairing member of the panel determines that information should be withheld, redacted or anonymised for any purpose specified in paragraph (2), the chairing member of the panel must—
(a)record the reasons for that determination, including the category of disclosure to which it applies, and
(b)ensure that the appropriate version of the report is prepared and used for that purpose.
(4)In considering the matters mentioned in paragraph (2), the chairing member of the panel may produce different versions of the report where the chairing member of the panel considers this to be necessary and proportionate, having regard to—
(a)the nature of the information concerned,
(b)the purpose of the disclosure,
(c)the rights and interests of any data subject.
(5)A report submitted to the Authority under paragraph (1) must—
(a)in a case where a final written warning has been given, explain the effect of regulation 24M(5), (6) and (7) in relation to any future misconduct allegation,
(b)include notice of the senior officer’s right to appeal the decision of the panel to impose disciplinary action to the First-tier Tribunal under section 56(1) or (1A) of the Act and the procedure for making such an appeal.
(6)As soon as practicable after receiving the report, the Authority must notify the senior officer of the outcome of the accelerated misconduct hearing by providing a copy of the report, subject to such withholding, redaction or anonymisation as the chairing member of the panel considers necessary in accordance with paragraph (2)(b).
(7)The Authority must provide a copy of the report to—
(a)the Commissioner,
(b)where the accelerated misconduct hearing arose from a complaint made by a member of the public, a constable, a member of the Authority’s staff or a member of police staff, the person who made the complaint,
subject to such withholding, redaction or anonymisation as the chairing member of the panel considers necessary in accordance with paragraph (2)(c).
(8)In determining what information may be withheld, redacted or anonymised for the purposes of paragraph (7), the chairing member of the panel must have particular regard to whether the information—
(a)comprises personal data relating to the senior officer or any other individual which is not necessary to enable the recipient to understand the outcome and reasoning of the panel, or
(b)relates to private or personal circumstances which do not materially affect the determination or disciplinary outcome.
(9)Subject to paragraph (11), the chairing member of the panel must require the Authority to publish a version of the report.
(10)In relation to publication, the chairing member of the panel may only withhold, redact or anonymise information in the report—
(a)insofar as the chairing member of the panel considers this is—
(i)necessary for the purpose of preventing the premature or inappropriate disclosure of information that is relevant to, or may be used in, criminal proceedings,
(ii)necessary for the purpose of the prevention or detection of crime, or the apprehension or prosecution of offenders,
(iii)necessary for the purpose of the prevention or detection of misconduct by other constables or police staff,
(iv)necessary and proportionate for the protection of the welfare and safety of any informant or witness, or
(v)otherwise in the public interest, and
(b)in line with restrictions imposed on the disclosure of information during the course of proceedings.
(11)The chairing member of the panel may dispense with the duty to require publishing of the report under paragraph (9) where, having regard to the matters set out in paragraph (10), the chairing member of the panel considers publication to be inappropriate in the particular circumstances of the case.
(12)In making a decision under paragraph (11), the chairing member of the panel may have regard to any representations made during the accelerated misconduct hearing.
(13)Information that has already lawfully been published during the course of the proceedings may not be withheld, redacted or anonymised for the purposes of publication under this regulation.
(14)Where the Authority is required to publish the report under paragraph (9), it must do so—
(a)as soon as practicable after the senior officer is notified under paragraph (6),
(b)on its website for a period of 28 days.”.
Annotations
Footnotes
- f1