Paragraph 55.3 Procedural hearingsF1
Scotland
In an intellectual property cause, not less than 3 days, or such other period as may be prescribed by the judge at the preliminary hearing, before the date fixed under rule 55.2E(4) for the procedural hearing, each party shall lodge in process and send to every other party—
a written statement of his proposals for further procedure which shall state—
whether he seeks to have any issue of law or fact (including validity, infringement, an application for amendment of a patent under section 75 of the Act of 1977, damages or other remedies sought) to be determined separately from any other issue;
whether he seeks to have the cause appointed to debate or to have the cause sent to proof on the whole or any part of it;
what the issues are which he considers should be sent to debate or proof; and
the estimated duration of any debate or proof;
where it is sought to have the cause appointed to proof, a list of the witness which the party proposes to cite or call to give evidence, identifying the matters to which each witness will speak;
where it is sought to have the cause appointed to proof, the reports of any skilled persons he proposes to call to give evidence;
where it is sought to have the cause appointed to debate, a note of argument consisting of concise numbered paragraphs stating the legal propositions on which it is proposed to submit that any preliminary plea should be sustained or repelled, with reference to the principal authorities and statutory provisions to be founded on; and
where it is sought to have any particular order made at a procedural hearing, a note giving written intimation of the order sought and the reason for seeking it.
At the procedural hearing, the judge—
shall determine whether to direct that any issue of law or fact (including validity, infringement, an application for amendment of a patent under section 75 of the Act of 1977, damages or other remedies sought) should be determined separately from any other issue;
shall determine whether the cause should be appointed to debate or to proof on the whole or any part of it;
shall determine whether to remit to the Patent Office for a Report and what the terms of the remit should be;
where the cause is appointed to debate, or is sent to proof, may order that written arguments on any question of law should be submitted;
where the cause is sent to proof, may determine whether evidence at the proof should be by oral evidence, the production of documents or affidavits on any issue;
where the cause is sent to proof, may direct that parties serve on one another and lodge in process signed witness statements or affidavits from each witness whose evidence they intend to adduce, setting out in full the evidence which it is intended to take from that witness, and fix a timetable for the service (whether by exchange or otherwise) and lodging of such statements or affidavits as may be thought necessary;
may direct that such witness statements or affidavits shall stand as evidence in chief of the witness concerned, subject to such further questioning in chief as the judge may allow;
where the cause is sent to proof, may appoint parties to be heard By Order at a date prior to the proof date;
may make an order regulating the making of any experiment, inspection, test or report;
may make an order restricting the number or disciplines of expert witnesses to be called by each party;
may direct that skilled persons should meet with a view to reaching agreement and identifying areas of disagreement, and may order them thereafter to produce a joint note, to be lodged in process by one of the parties, identifying areas of agreement and disagreement, and the basis of any disagreement;
may determine, in the light of any witness statements, affidavits or reports produced, that proof is unnecessary on any issue;
without prejudice to Chapter 12 (assessors), may appoint an expert to examine, on behalf of the court, any reports of skilled persons or other evidence submitted and to report to the court within such period as the judge may specify;
may remit an issue to a person of skill appointed by the court;
may fix a date by which, notwithstanding rule 36.3 (lodging productions for proofs) any documents intended to be relied on by a party shall be lodged in process or, if more appropriate, be intimated to all other parties with a view to those documents being lodged in process as part of an agreed bundle of documents;
may make an order for parties to produce a joint bundle of productions arranged in chronological order or such other order as will assist in the efficient conduct of the proof;
may fix a date by which a notice under rule 55.4 (notice to admit and notices of non-admission) shall be served;
where the cause is sent to proof, may make an order fixing the time allowed for the examination and cross-examination of witnesses;
may, on the motion of a party, direct the cause to be determined on the basis of written submissions, or such other material, without any oral hearing;
may continue the procedural hearing to a date to be appointed by the judge;
may order and fix a date for a further procedural hearing or fix a date for the hearing of any debate or proof; and
may make such other order as the judge thinks fit.
Chapter 28 (procedure roll) shall apply to a debate ordered in an intellectual property cause under this rule as it applies to a cause appointed to the Procedure Roll.
Annotations
Textual amendments
- F1
Sch. 2 rules 55.2B-55.3A substituted for Sch. 2 rule 55.3 (19.11.2012) by Act of Sederunt (Rules of the Court of Session Amendment No. 5) (Miscellaneous) 2012 (S.S.I. 2012/275), paras. 1(1), 3(3)
Notes on Schedule 2
Modifications
- C1
Sch. 2 amendment to earlier amending provision SSI 2015/228 para. 3(5) Sch. 1 (21.9.2015) by Act of Sederunt (Ordinary Cause Rules 1993 Amendment and Miscellaneous Amendments) 2015 (S.S.I. 2015/296), paras. 1(2), 3(3)