OpenLegislation

Commission Implementing Decision of 26 February 2013 on excluding from European Union financing certain expenditure incurred by the Member States under the Guarantee Section of the European Agricultural Guidance and Guarantee Fund (EAGGF), under the European Agricultural Guarantee Fund (EAGF) and under the European Agricultural Fund for Rural Development (EAFRD) (notified under document C(2013) 981) (Only the Bulgarian, Czech, Danish, Dutch, English, Finnish, French, German, Greek, Hungarian, Italian, Lithuanian, Maltese, Polish, Romanian, Slovak, Slovenian, Spanish and Swedish texts are authentic) (2013/123/EU)

EU Decision 2013/123 · Adopted 26 February 2013 · Extends to United Kingdom

Original text. legislation.gov.uk does not revise this item, so later amendments are not shown here. Changes made to it are listed under each provision when known.

Commission Implementing Decision

of 26 February 2013

on excluding from European Union financing certain expenditure incurred by the Member States under the Guarantee Section of the European Agricultural Guidance and Guarantee Fund (EAGGF), under the European Agricultural Guarantee Fund (EAGF) and under the European Agricultural Fund for Rural Development (EAFRD)

(notified under document C(2013) 981)

(Only the Bulgarian, Czech, Danish, Dutch, English, Finnish, French, German, Greek, Hungarian, Italian, Lithuanian, Maltese, Polish, Romanian, Slovak, Slovenian, Spanish and Swedish texts are authentic)

(2013/123/EU)

THE EUROPEAN COMMISSION,

Having regard to the Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union,

Having regard to Council Regulation (EC) No 1258/1999 of 17 May 1999 on the financing of the common agricultural policyf1, and in particular Article 7(4) thereof,

Having regard to Council Regulation (EC) No 1290/2005 of 21 June 2005 on the financing of the common agricultural policyf2, and in particular Article 31 thereof,

Having consulted the Committee on the Agricultural Funds,

Whereas:

(1)

Under Article 7(4) of Regulation (EC) No 1258/1999, and Article 31 of Regulation (EC) No 1290/2005, the Commission is to carry out the necessary verifications, communicate to the Member States the results of these verifications, take note of the comments of the Member States, initiate a bilateral discussion so that an agreement may be reached with the Member States in question, and formally communicate its conclusions to them.

(2)

The Member States have had an opportunity to request the launch of a conciliation procedure. That opportunity has been used in some cases and the reports issued on the outcome have been examined by the Commission.

(3)

Under Regulations (EC) No 1258/1999 and (EC) No 1290/2005, only agricultural expenditure which has been incurred in a way that has not infringed European Union rules may be financed.

(4)

In the light of the verifications carried out, the outcome of the bilateral discussions and the conciliation procedures, part of the expenditure declared by the Member States does not fulfil this requirement and cannot, therefore, be financed under the EAGGF Guarantee Section, the EAGF and the EAFRD.

(5)

The amounts that are not recognised as being chargeable to the EAGGF Guarantee Section, the EAGF and the EAFRD should be indicated. Those amounts do not relate to expenditure incurred more than 24 months before the Commission’s written notification of the results of the verifications to the Member States.

(6)

As regards the cases covered by this decision, the assessment of the amounts to be excluded on grounds of non-compliance with European Union rules was notified by the Commission to the Member States in a summary report on the subject.

(7)

This Decision is without prejudice to any financial conclusions that the Commission may draw from the judgments of the Court of Justice in cases pending on 15 October 2012 and relating to its content,

HAS ADOPTED THIS DECISION:

Annotations to the whole text

Footnotes

f1

OJ L 160, 26.6.1999, p. 103.

f2

OJ L 209, 11.8.2005, p. 1.

Contents

  1. 1Article 1
  2. 2Article 2
  3. Signature
  4. Annex Annex

1

The expenditure itemised in the Annex hereto that has been incurred by the Member States’ accredited paying agencies and declared under the EAGGF Guarantee Section, under the EAGF or under the EAFRD shall be excluded from European Union financing because it does not comply with European Union rules.

2

This Decision is addressed to the Kingdom of Belgium, the Republic of Bulgaria, the Czech Republic, the Kingdom of Denmark, the Federal Republic of Germany, Ireland, the Hellenic Republic, the Kingdom of Spain, the French Republic, the Italian Republic, the Republic of Cyprus, the Republic of Lithuania, Hungary, the Republic of Malta, the Kingdom of the Netherlands, the Republic of Poland, Romania, the Republic of Slovenia, the Slovak Republic, the Republic of Finland, the Kingdom of Sweden and the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland.

Signature

Done at Brussels, 26 February 2013.

For the Commission

Dacian Cioloș

Member of the Commission

Member StateMeasureFinancial YearReasonType%CurrencyAmountDeductionsFinancial impact
BUDGET ITEM: 6701
BECross Compliance2006GAEC not implemented, partial on-the-spot controls, claim year 2005FLAT RATE5,0 %EUR-93 217,10,0-93 217,1
BECross Compliance2007GAEC not implemented, partial on-the-spot controls, claim year 2005FLAT RATE5,0 %EUR152,330,0152,33
BECross Compliance2007GAEC not implemented, partial on-the-spot controls, claim year 2006FLAT RATE5,0 %EUR-869 463,150,0-869 463,15
BECross Compliance2008GAEC not implemented, partial on-the-spot controls, claim year 2005FLAT RATE5,0 %EUR4,890,04,89
BECross Compliance2008GAEC not implemented, partial on-the-spot controls, claim year 2006FLAT RATE5,0 %EUR252,090,0252,09
BECross Compliance2008GAEC not implemented, partial on-the-spot controls, claim year 2007FLAT RATE5,0 %EUR-1 481 485,190,0-1 481 485,19
BECross Compliance2009GAEC not implemented, partial on-the-spot controls, Claim 2005FLAT RATE5,0 %EUR28,080,028,08
BECross Compliance2009GAEC not implemented, partial on-the-spot controls, claim year 2006FLAT RATE5,0 %EUR19,780,019,78
BECross Compliance2009GAEC not implemented, partial on-the-spot controls, claim year 2007FLAT RATE5,0 %EUR49,340,049,34
BECross Compliance2010GAEC not implemented, partial on-the-spot controls, claim year 2007FLAT RATE5,0 %EUR-70,550,0-70,55
TOTAL BEEUR-2 443 729,480,0-2 443 729,48
CYFinancial audit - Overshooting2011exceeding of ceilingsONE-OFFEUR-26,69-26,690,0
TOTAL CYEUR-26,69-26,690,0
CZCross Compliance2007GAEC non defined, weaknesses in evaluation of non compliances, claim year 2006FLAT RATE5,0 %EUR-985 525,730,0-985 525,73
CZCross Compliance2008GAEC non defined, weaknesses in evaluation of non compliances, claim year 2006FLAT RATE5,0 %EUR-355,610,0-355,61
CZCross Compliance2008GAEC non defined, weaknesses in evaluation of non compliances, claim year 2007FLAT RATE5,0 %EUR-1 901 569,160,0-1 901 569,16
CZCross Compliance2009GAEC non defined, weaknesses in evaluation of non compliances, claim year 2006FLAT RATE5,0 %EUR-19,890,0-19,89
CZCross Compliance2009GAEC non defined, weaknesses in evaluation of non compliances, claim year 2007FLAT RATE5,0 %EUR-1 546,950,0-1 546,95
CZCross Compliance2009GAEC non defined, weaknesses in evaluation of non compliances, claim year 2008FLAT RATE5,0 %EUR-2 366 879,570,0-2 366 879,57
TOTAL CZEUR-5 255 896,910,0-5 255 896,91
DKIrregularities2011deficiencies in the recovery of a debt caseONE-OFFDKK-142 645,00,0-142 645,0
TOTAL DKDKK-142 645,00,0-142 645,0
ESEntitlements2007forage area non-inclusion in the calculation of the reference area/ amountsFLAT RATE5,0 %EUR-1 969 526,340,0-1 969 526,34
ESEntitlements2007deficiencies in the national reserve allocation for the investments into olive sectorFLAT RATE5,0 %EUR-1 435 445,920,0-1 435 445,92
ESEntitlements2007deficiencies in the calculation of payment entitlements for bovine premiumONE-OFFEUR-718 490,480,0-718 490,48
ESEntitlements2007wrong application of the exceptional circumstances clause in sugar sectorONE-OFFEUR-107 390,070,0-107 390,07
ESEntitlements2008forage area non-inclusion in the calculation of the reference area/ amountsFLAT RATE5,0 %EUR-2 140 711,780,0-2 140 711,78
ESEntitlements2008deficiencies in the national reserve allocation for the investments into olive sectorFLAT RATE5,0 %EUR-1 441 201,280,0-1 441 201,28
ESEntitlements2008deficiencies in the calculation of payment entitlements for bovine premiumONE-OFFEUR-721 414,450,0-721 414,45
ESEntitlements2008wrong application of the exceptional circumstances clause in sugar sectorONE-OFFEUR-136 846,50,0-136 846,5
ESEntitlements2009deficiencies in the national reserve allocation for the investments into olive sectorFLAT RATE5,0 %EUR-1 453 007,150,0-1 453 007,15
ESEntitlements2009forage area non-inclusion in the calculation of the reference area/ amountsFLAT RATE10,0 %EUR-5 060 486,510,0-5 060 486,51
ESEntitlements2009deficiencies in the calculation of payment entitlements for bovine premiumONE-OFFEUR-687 715,790,0-687 715,79
ESEntitlements2009wrong application of the exceptional circumstances clause in sugar sectorONE-OFFEUR-157 667,860,0-157 667,86
ESExport refunds - Non-Annex I2002deficient ex ante checks on beef, weaknesses in execution of physical checks, inadequate checks on production and stock of sugar, advance notice of physical checks given to the exportersFLAT RATE25,0 %EUR-451 439,060,0-451 439,06
ESExport refunds - Non-Annex I2002deficient ex ante checks on beef, weaknesses in execution of physical checks, inadequate checks on production and stock of sugar, advance notice of physical checks given to the exportersONE-OFFEUR-8 255 792,170,0-8 255 792,17
ESExport refunds - Non-Annex I2003deficient ex ante checks on beef, weaknesses in execution of physical checks, inadequate checks on production and stock of sugar, advance notice of physical checks given to the exportersFLAT RATE2,0 %EUR-625 835,590,0-625 835,59
ESExport refunds - Non-Annex I2003deficient ex ante checks on beef, weaknesses in execution of physical checks, inadequate checks on production and stock of sugar, advance notice of physical checks given to the exportersFLAT RATE10,0 %EUR-283 466,310,0-283 466,31
ESExport refunds - Non-Annex I2003deficient ex ante checks on beef, weaknesses in execution of physical checks, inadequate checks on production and stock of sugar, advance notice of physical checks given to the exportersFLAT RATE25,0 %EUR-637 325,710,0-637 325,71
ESExport refunds - Non-Annex I2003deficient ex ante checks on beef, weaknesses in execution of physical checks, inadequate checks on production and stock of sugar, advance notice of physical checks given to the exportersONE-OFFEUR-10 428 368,990,0-10 428 368,99
ESExport refunds - Non-Annex I2004deficient ex ante checks on beef, weaknesses in execution of physical checks, inadequate checks on production and stock of sugar, advance notice of physical checks given to the exportersFLAT RATE2,0 %EUR-543 032,760,0-543 032,76
ESExport refunds - Non-Annex I2004deficient ex ante checks on beef, weaknesses in execution of physical checks, inadequate checks on production and stock of sugar, advance notice of physical checks given to the exportersFLAT RATE2,0 %EUR-612 356,110,0-612 356,11
ESExport refunds - Non-Annex I2004deficient ex ante checks on beef, weaknesses in execution of physical checks, inadequate checks on production and stock of sugar, advance notice of physical checks given to the exportersFLAT RATE10,0 %EUR-85 673,90,0-85 673,9
ESExport refunds - Non-Annex I2004deficient ex ante checks on beef, weaknesses in execution of physical checks, inadequate checks on production and stock of sugar, advance notice of physical checks given to the exportersFLAT RATE10,0 %EUR-420 186,530,0-420 186,53
ESExport refunds - Non-Annex I2004deficient ex ante checks on beef, weaknesses in execution of physical checks, inadequate checks on production and stock of sugar, advance notice of physical checks given to the exportersFLAT RATE25,0 %EUR-637 325,720,0-637 325,72
ESExport refunds - Non-Annex I2004deficient ex ante checks on beef, weaknesses in execution of physical checks, inadequate checks on production and stock of sugar, advance notice of physical checks given to the exportersONE-OFFEUR-10 428 369,250,0-10 428 369,25
ESExport refunds - Non-Annex I2005deficient ex ante checks on beef, weaknesses in execution of physical checks, inadequate checks on production and stock of sugar, advance notice of physical checks given to the exportersFLAT RATE2,0 %EUR-644 593,50,0-644 593,5
ESExport refunds - Non-Annex I2005deficient ex ante checks on beef, weaknesses in execution of physical checks, inadequate checks on production and stock of sugar, advance notice of physical checks given to the exportersFLAT RATE2,0 %EUR-1 197 102,190,0-1 197 102,19
ESExport refunds - Non-Annex I2005deficient ex ante checks on beef, weaknesses in execution of physical checks, inadequate checks on production and stock of sugar, advance notice of physical checks given to the exportersFLAT RATE10,0 %EUR-29 829,440,0-29 829,44
ESExport refunds - other2005deficient ex ante checks on beef, weaknesses in execution of physical checks, inadequate checks on production and stock of sugar, advance notice of physical checks given to the exportersFLAT RATE10,0 %EUR-3 070,580,0-3 070,58
ESExport refunds - Non-Annex I2005deficient ex ante checks on beef, weaknesses in execution of physical checks, inadequate checks on production and stock of sugar, advance notice of physical checks given to the exportersFLAT RATE10,0 %EUR-73 612,220,0-73 612,22
ESExport refunds - Non-Annex I2005deficient ex ante checks on beef, weaknesses in execution of physical checks, inadequate checks on production and stock of sugar, advance notice of physical checks given to the exportersFLAT RATE25,0 %EUR-79 665,710,0-79 665,71
ESExport refunds - Non-Annex I2005deficient ex ante checks on beef, weaknesses in execution of physical checks, inadequate checks on production and stock of sugar, advance notice of physical checks given to the exportersONE-OFFEUR-1 303 546,060,0-1 303 546,06
ESExport refunds - Non-Annex I2006deficient ex ante checks on beef, weaknesses in execution of physical checks, inadequate checks on production and stock of sugar, advance notice of physical checks given to the exportersFLAT RATE2,0 %EUR-114 829,310,0-114 829,31
ESExport refunds - Live animals2006deficient ex ante checks on beef, weaknesses in execution of physical checks, inadequate checks on production and stock of sugar, advance notice of physical checks given to the exportersFLAT RATE2,0 %EUR-12 087,30,0-12 087,3
ESExport refunds - other2006deficient ex ante checks on beef, weaknesses in execution of physical checks, inadequate checks on production and stock of sugar, advance notice of physical checks given to the exportersFLAT RATE2,0 %EUR-368 662,520,0-368 662,52
ESExport refunds - Sugar and isoglucose2006deficient ex ante checks on beef, weaknesses in execution of physical checks, inadequate checks on production and stock of sugar, advance notice of physical checks given to the exportersFLAT RATE10,0 %EUR-1 568 548,490,0-1 568 548,49
ESExport refunds - Non-Annex I2006deficient ex ante checks on beef, weaknesses in execution of physical checks, inadequate checks on production and stock of sugar, advance notice of physical checks given to the exportersFLAT RATE10,0 %EUR-1 792,30,0-1 792,3
ESExport refunds - other2006deficient ex ante checks on beef, weaknesses in execution of physical checks, inadequate checks on production and stock of sugar, advance notice of physical checks given to the exportersFLAT RATE10,0 %EUR-1 792,30,0-1 792,3
ESExport refunds - other2006deficient ex ante checks on beef, weaknesses in execution of physical checks, inadequate checks on production and stock of sugar, advance notice of physical checks given to the exportersONE-OFFEUR-108 785,660,0-108 785,66
ESExport refunds - other2007deficient ex ante checks on beef, weaknesses in execution of physical checks, inadequate checks on production and stock of sugar, advance notice of physical checks given to the exportersFLAT RATE2,0 %EUR-233 717,840,0-233 717,84
ESExport refunds - Non-Annex I2007deficient ex ante checks on beef, weaknesses in execution of physical checks, inadequate checks on production and stock of sugar, advance notice of physical checks given to the exportersFLAT RATE2,0 %EUR-9 738,240,0-9 738,24
ESExport refunds - Sugar and isoglucose2007deficient ex ante checks on beef, weaknesses in execution of physical checks, inadequate checks on production and stock of sugar, advance notice of physical checks given to the exportersFLAT RATE10,0 %EUR-883 426,040,0-883 426,04
ESExport refunds - other2007deficient ex ante checks on beef, weaknesses in execution of physical checks, inadequate checks on production and stock of sugar, advance notice of physical checks given to the exportersFLAT RATE10,0 %EUR-762,460,0-762,46
ESExport refunds - Non-Annex I2007deficient ex ante checks on beef, weaknesses in execution of physical checks, inadequate checks on production and stock of sugar, advance notice of physical checks given to the exportersFLAT RATE10,0 %EUR-676,140,0-676,14
ESExport refunds - Non-Annex I2008deficient ex ante checks on beef, weaknesses in execution of physical checks, inadequate checks on production and stock of sugar, advance notice of physical checks given to the exportersFLAT RATE2,0 %EUR-47 777,240,0-47 777,24
ESExport refunds - other2008deficient ex ante checks on beef, weaknesses in execution of physical checks, inadequate checks on production and stock of sugar, advance notice of physical checks given to the exportersFLAT RATE2,0 %EUR-191 108,960,0-191 108,96
ESExport refunds - Sugar and isoglucose2008deficient ex ante checks on beef, weaknesses in execution of physical checks, inadequate checks on production and stock of sugar, advance notice of physical checks given to the exportersFLAT RATE10,0 %EUR-310 869,70,0-310 869,7
ESExport refunds - other2008deficient ex ante checks on beef, weaknesses in execution of physical checks, inadequate checks on production and stock of sugar, advance notice of physical checks given to the exportersFLAT RATE10,0 %EUR-1 043,650,0-1 043,65
ESIrregularities2007reimbursment due to rectification of the Annex III table for financial year 2006ONE-OFFEUR1 998 905,540,01 998 905,54
ESIrregularities2011weakness in the recovery procedure of a debtONE-OFFEUR-214 008,50,0-214 008,5
ESCross Compliance20061 GAEC missing, weaknesses in effectiveness of controls and in application of reduction, claim year 2005FLAT RATE5,0 %EUR-2 049 444,68-470,83-2 048 973,85
ESCross Compliance20071 GAEC missing, weaknesses in effectiveness of controls and in application of reduction, claim year 2005FLAT RATE5,0 %EUR-9 678,620,0-9 678,62
ESCross Compliance20071 GAEC missing, weaknesses in effectiveness of controls and in application of reduction, claim year 2005FLAT RATE5,0 %EUR41,870,041,87
ESCross Compliance20071 GAEC missing, weaknesses in effectiveness of controls and in application of reduction, claim year 2006FLAT RATE5,0 %EUR-4 385 343,3-387,58-4 384 955,72
ESCross Compliance20071 GAEC missing, weaknesses in effectiveness of controls and in application of reduction, claim year 2006FLAT RATE5,0 %EUR181,890,0181,89
ESCross Compliance20081 GAEC missing, weaknesses in effectiveness of controls and in application of reduction, claim year 2005FLAT RATE5,0 %EUR-3 017,650,0-3 017,65
ESCross Compliance20081 GAEC missing, weaknesses in effectiveness of controls and in application of reduction, claim year 2005FLAT RATE5,0 %EUR0,840,00,84
ESCross Compliance20081 GAEC missing, weaknesses in effectiveness of controls and in application of reduction, claim year 2006FLAT RATE5,0 %EUR-35 502,66-2,94-35 499,72
ESCross Compliance20081 GAEC missing, weaknesses in effectiveness of controls and in application of reduction, claim year 2006FLAT RATE5,0 %EUR50,650,050,65
ESCross Compliance20091 GAEC missing, weaknesses in effectiveness of controls and in application of reduction, claim year 2005FLAT RATE5,0 %EUR-2 196,120,0-2 196,12
ESCross Compliance20091 GAEC missing, weaknesses in effectiveness of controls and in application of reduction, claim year 2005FLAT RATE5,0 %EUR30,80,030,8
ESCross Compliance20091 GAEC missing, weaknesses in effectiveness of controls and in application of reduction, claim year 2006FLAT RATE5,0 %EUR-1 229,560,0-1 229,56
ESCross Compliance20091 GAEC missing, Effectiveness of controls, Application of reduction, claim year 2006FLAT RATE5,0 %EUR256,70,0256,7
TOTAL ESEUR-61 327 066,88-861,35-61 326 205,53
FIClearance of accounts - Financial Clearance2009errors detected during the certification exercise for financial year 2009 in EAGF populationONE-OFFEUR-64 880,770,0-64 880,77
TOTAL FIEUR-64 880,770,0-64 880,77
FRFinancial audit - Late payments and payment deadlines2011Late paymentsONE-OFFEUR-138 405,9-138 405,90,0
FRFinancial audit - Late payments and payment deadlines2011Late paymentsONE-OFFEUR-1 233 451,34-1 233 451,340,0
FRCertification2008Ineligible expenditureONE-OFFEUR-108 312,830,0-108 312,83
FROther Direct Aid - Ewe and Goats2007non-compliant holding register, lack of verification of accuracy of entries to the register, update of the register later than on-the-spot check, non-compliance of the computer databaseFLAT RATE2,0 %EUR-1 552 358,26-9 314,14-1 543 044,12
FROther Direct Aid - Ewe and Goats2008non-compliant holding register, lack of verification of accuracy of entries to the register, update of the register later than on-the-spot check, non-compliance of the computer databaseFLAT RATE2,0 %EUR-1 492 340,470,0-1 492 340,47
FROther Direct Aid - Ewe and Goats2009non-compliant holding register, lack of verification of accuracy of entries to the register, update of the register later than on-the-spot check, non-compliance of the computer databaseFLAT RATE2,0 %EUR-1 429 479,120,0-1 429 479,12
FROther Direct Aid - Ewe and Goats2010non-compliant holding register, lack of verification of accuracy of entries to the register, update of the register later than on-the-spot check, non-compliance of the computer databaseFLAT RATE2,0 %EUR-109,820,0-109,82
TOTAL FREUR-5 954 457,74-1 381 171,38-4 573 286,36
GBDecoupled Direct Aids2008weaknesses in LPIS-GIS, in processing of applications, in administrative cross checks, in on-the-spot controlsFLAT RATE2,0 %EUR-27 569 252,08-11 938 317,64-15 630 934,44
GBOther Direct Aid - Energy Crops2008weaknesses in LPIS-GIS, in processing of applications, in administrative cross checks, in on-the-spot controlsFLAT RATE2,0 %EUR-99 998,30,0-99 998,3
GBOther Direct Aids2008weaknesses in LPIS-GIS, in processing of applications, in administrative cross checks, in on-the-spot controlsFLAT RATE2,0 %EUR-88 938,90,0-88 938,9
GBOther Direct Aids2009weaknesses in LPIS-GIS, in processing of applications, in administrative cross checks, in on-the-spot controlsFLAT RATE2,0 %EUR-107 725,590,0-107 725,59
GBDecoupled Direct Aids2009weaknesses in LPIS-GIS, in processing of applications, in administrative cross checks, in on-the-spot controlsFLAT RATE2,0 %EUR-41 109 525,750,0-41 109 525,75
GBOther Direct Aid - Energy Crops2009weaknesses in LPIS-GIS, in processing of applications, in administrative cross checks, in on-the-spot controlsFLAT RATE2,0 %EUR-31 594,40,0-31 594,4
GBDecoupled Direct Aids2010weaknesses in LPIS-GIS, in processing of applications, in administrative cross checks, in on-the-spot controlsFLAT RATE2,0 %EUR-41 490 749,020,0-41 490 749,02
GBOther Direct Aids2010weaknesses in LPIS-GIS, in processing of applications, in administrative cross checks, in on-the-spot controlsFLAT RATE2,0 %EUR-174 763,240,0-174 763,24
GBOther Direct Aid - Energy Crops2010weaknesses in LPIS-GIS, in processing of applications, in administrative cross checks, in on-the-spot controlsFLAT RATE2,0 %EUR-63 023,440,0-63 023,44
GBDecoupled Direct Aids2010Weaknesses in LPIS-GIS, in the on-the-spot checks and payments and sanctionsEXTRAPOLATED5,19 %EUR-16 513 582,57-1 954 694,52-14 558 888,05
GBIrregularities2011Deficiencies in the recovery of a debt caseONE-OFFGBP-1 452 109,170,0-1 452 109,17
GBCross Compliance2007Lenient sanctioning system, claim year 2006FLAT RATE5,0 %EUR-73 257,360,0-73 257,36
GBCross Compliance2008Lenient sanctioning system, claim year 2006FLAT RATE5,0 %EUR-4 064,430,0-4 064,43
GBCross Compliance2008Lenient sanctioning system, claim year 2007FLAT RATE5,0 %EUR-1 643 405,41-700,4-1 642 705,01
GBCross Compliance2009Minimum requirements on fertilisers and plant protection and one SMR not adequately controlled, claim year 2008FLAT RATE2,0 %EUR-642 321,160,0-642 321,16
GBCross Compliance2009Lenient sanctioning system, claim year 2006FLAT RATE5,0 %EUR-521,540,0-521,54
GBCross Compliance2009Lenient sanctioning system, claim year 2007FLAT RATE5,0 %EUR-5 359,10,0-5 359,1
GBCross Compliance2010Minimum requirements on fertilisers and plant protection and one SMR not adequately controlled, claim year 2008FLAT RATE2,0 %EUR-712,310,0-712,31
GBCross Compliance2010Lenient sanctioning system, claim year 2007FLAT RATE5,0 %EUR-536,910,0-536,91
TOTAL GBGBP-1 452 109,170,0-1 452 109,17
TOTAL GBEUR-129 619 331,51-13 893 712,56-115 725 618,95
GRFinancial audit - Overshooting2010Exceeding of ceilingsONE-OFFEUR-4 048 593,820,0-4 048 593,82
GRFinancial audit - Late payments and payment deadlines2010late paymentsONE-OFFEUR-11 217,98-11 217,980,0
GRFinancial audit - Late payments and payment deadlines2010late paymentsONE-OFFEUR-1 148 947,18-375 753,63-773 193,55
GRFood Aid within the Community2006Overpaid public storage costsONE-OFFEUR-58 833,00,0-58 833,0
GRPublic Storage - Rice2006Overpaid public storage costsONE-OFFEUR-369 174,820,0-369 174,82
GROther Direct Aid - Article 69 of Reg.1782/2003 - only Ovines and Bovines2007control free period, weaknesses in determination of the eligibility criteria, in the risk analysis and in the on-the-spot cpntrols, lack of quality supervision for the delegated controlsFLAT RATE5,0 %EUR-1 016 633,470,0-1 016 633,47
GROther Direct Aid - Article 69 of Reg.1782/2003 - only Ovines and Bovines2007change of the eligibility criteria after the end of the claim year 2006ONE-OFFEUR-1 246 345,920,0-1 246 345,92
GROther Direct Aid - Article 69 of Reg.1782/2003 - except Ovines and Bovines2007control free period, weaknesses in determination of the eligibility criteria, in the risk analysis and in the on-the-spot cpntrols, lack of quality supervision for the delegated controlsFLAT RATE5,0 %EUR-358 518,510,0-358 518,51
GROther Direct Aid - Article 69 of Reg.1782/2003 - only Ovines and Bovines2008control free period, weaknesses in determination of the eligibility criteria, in the risk analysis and in the on-the-spot cpntrols, lack of quality supervision for the delegated controlsFLAT RATE2,0 %EUR-125 128,340,0-125 128,34
GROther Direct Aid - Article 69 of Reg.1782/2003 - only Ovines and Bovines2008control free period, weaknesses in determination of the eligibility criteria, in the risk analysis and in the on-the-spot cpntrols, lack of quality supervision for the delegated controlsFLAT RATE5,0 %EUR-567 077,510,0-567 077,51
GROther Direct Aid - Article 69 of Reg.1782/2003 - except Ovines and Bovines2008control free period, weaknesses in determination of the eligibility criteria, in the risk analysis and in the on-the-spot cpntrols, lack of quality supervision for the delegated controlsFLAT RATE5,0 %EUR-339 319,370,0-339 319,37
GROther Direct Aid - Article 69 of Reg.1782/2003 - except Ovines and Bovines2008control free period, weaknesses in determination of the eligibility criteria, in the risk analysis and in the on-the-spot cpntrols, lack of quality supervision for the delegated controlsFLAT RATE5,0 %EUR12,580,012,58
GROther Direct Aid - Article 69 of Reg.1782/2003 - only Ovines and Bovines2009control free period, weaknesses in determination of the eligibility criteria, in the risk analysis and in the on-the-spot cpntrols, lack of quality supervision for the delegated controlsFLAT RATE2,0 %EUR-23 367,160,0-23 367,16
GROther Direct Aid - Article 69 of Reg.1782/2003 - except Ovines and Bovines2009control free period, weaknesses in determination of the eligibility criteria, in the risk analysis and in the on-the-spot cpntrols, lack of quality supervision for the delegated controlsFLAT RATE5,0 %EUR-10 743,310,0-10 743,31
GROther Direct Aid - Article 69 of Reg.1782/2003 - only Ovines and Bovines2009control free period, weaknesses in determination of the eligibility criteria, in the risk analysis and in the on-the-spot cpntrols, lack of quality supervision for the delegated controlsFLAT RATE5,0 %EUR1 998,070,01 998,07
GROther Direct Aid - Article 69 of Reg.1782/2003 - except Ovines and Bovines2009control free period, weaknesses in determination of the eligibility criteria, in the risk analysis and in the on-the-spot cpntrols, lack of quality supervision for the delegated controlsFLAT RATE5,0 %EUR-1 066,260,0-1 066,26
TOTAL GREUR-9 322 956,0-386 971,61-8 935 984,39
HUCross Compliance20068 GAEC not defined, claim year 2005FLAT RATE10,0 %HUF-281 162 836,1-5 622 679,91-275 540 156,19
HUCross Compliance20078 GAEC not defined, claim year 2005FLAT RATE10,0 %EUR-1 456,02-1 403,78-52,24
HUCross Compliance20078 GAEC not defined, claim year 2006FLAT RATE10,0 %EUR-2 836 628,7-21 435,09-2 815 193,61
HUCross Compliance20088 GAEC not defined, claim year 2005FLAT RATE10,0 %EUR23,590,023,59
HUCross Compliance20088 GAEC not defined, claim year 2006FLAT RATE10,0 %EUR387,67-32,6420,27
HUCross Compliance20088 GAEC not defined, claim year 2007FLAT RATE10,0 %EUR-5 428 019,24-28 383,73-5 399 635,51
HUCross Compliance20098 GAEC not defined, claim year 2005FLAT RATE10,0 %EUR-101,510,0-101,51
HUCross Compliance20098 GAEC not defined, claim year 2006FLAT RATE10,0 %EUR-416,760,0-416,76
HUCross Compliance20098 GAEC not defined, claim year 2007FLAT RATE10,0 %EUR-8 066,230,0-8 066,23
TOTAL HUHUF-281 162 836,1-5 622 679,91-275 540 156,19
TOTAL HUEUR-8 274 277,2-51 255,2-8 223 022,0
IEFinancial audit - Late payments and payment deadlines2011late paymentsONE-OFFEUR-13 215,75-13 215,750,0
IEIrregularities2007Non-reporting of interest in the Annex III table of financial year 2006ONE-OFFEUR-3 606,20,0-3 606,2
IEIrregularities2008Non-reporting of interest in the Annex III table of financial year 2007ONE-OFFEUR-1 048,990,0-1 048,99
IEIrregularities2009Non-reporting of interest in the Annex III table of financial year 2008ONE-OFFEUR-2 109,230,0-2 109,23
IEIrregularities2010Non-reporting of interest in the Annex III table of financial year 2009ONE-OFFEUR-892,440,0-892,44
IEIrregularities2011Negligence in recovering the debtONE-OFFEUR-22 624,220,0-22 624,22
TOTAL IEEUR-43 496,83-13 215,75-30 281,08
ITCross Compliance2006Several SMRs badly controlled, wrong application of correction, for farmers without animals - claim year 2005FLAT RATE5,0 %EUR-2 140 320,86-521,76-2 139 799,1
ITCross Compliance2006Several SMRs badly controlled, wrong application of correction, for farmers without animals - claim year 2005FLAT RATE5,0 %EUR-17,570,0-17,57
ITCross Compliance2006Several SMRs badly controlled, wrong application of correction, for farmers with animals - claim year 2005FLAT RATE10,0 %EUR-3 799 568,8-877,18-3 798 691,62
ITCross Compliance2006Several SMRs badly controlled, wrong application of correction, for farmers with animals - claim year 2005FLAT RATE10,0 %EUR-588,40,0-588,4
ITCross Compliance2007Several SMRs badly controlled, wrong application of correction, for farmers without animals - claim year 2006FLAT RATE5,0 %EUR-7 065 635,65-60 023,03-7 005 612,62
ITCross Compliance2007Several SMRs badly controlled, wrong application of correction, for farmers without animals - claim year 2006FLAT RATE5,0 %EUR-5 975,350,0-5 975,35
ITCross Compliance2007Several SMRs badly controlled, wrong application of correction, for farmers with animals - claim year 2006FLAT RATE10,0 %EUR-8 809 763,62-53 375,69-8 756 387,93
ITCross Compliance2007Several SMRs badly controlled, wrong application of correction, for farmers with animals - claim year 2006FLAT RATE10,0 %EUR-19 257,410,0-19 257,41
ITCross Compliance2008Several SMRs badly controlled, wrong application of correction, for farmers without animals - claim year 2007FLAT RATE5,0 %EUR-11 214 946,03-43 992,23-11 170 953,8
ITCross Compliance2008Several SMRs badly controlled, wrong application of correction, for farmers without animals - claim year 2007FLAT RATE5,0 %EUR-698 146,260,0-698 146,26
ITCross Compliance2008Several SMRs badly controlled, wrong application of correction, for farmers with animals - claim year 2007FLAT RATE10,0 %EUR-14 331 663,3-48 186,16-14 283 477,14
ITCross Compliance2008Several SMRs badly controlled, wrong application of correction, for farmers with animals - claim year 2007FLAT RATE10,0 %EUR-216 402,75-74,09-216 328,66
ITFinancial audit - Late payments and payment deadlines2011late paymentsONE-OFFEUR-2 458 104,43-2 458 104,430,0
ITMilk - Quota2011recovery of milk levyONE-OFFEUR163 991,21163 991,210,0
ITAccreditation Paying Agency2007deficiencies in the accreditation criteria for EAGFFLAT RATE16,0 %EUR-3 248,920,0-3 248,92
ITAccreditation Paying Agency2007deficiencies in the accreditation criteria for EAGF (debtors)FLAT RATE16,0 %EUR-64 771,050,0-64 771,05
ITAccreditation Paying Agency2008deficiencies in the accreditation criteria for EAGFFLAT RATE16,0 %EUR-2 527,190,0-2 527,19
ITAccreditation Paying Agency2008deficiencies in the accreditation criteria for EAGF (debtors)FLAT RATE16,0 %EUR-119 653,30,0-119 653,3
ITAccreditation Paying Agency2009deficiencies in the accreditation criteria for EAGFFLAT RATE16,0 %EUR-445 807,980,0-445 807,98
ITAccreditation Paying Agency2009deficiencies in the accreditation criteria for EAGF (debtors)FLAT RATE16,0 %EUR-118 662,340,0-118 662,34
ITFruit and Vegetables - Citrus Processing2005Gravely deficient control system, fraudFLAT RATE25,0 %EUR-17 098 044,580,0-17 098 044,58
ITFruit and Vegetables - Citrus Processing2006Gravely deficient control system, fraudFLAT RATE25,0 %EUR-817 132,980,0-817 132,98
ITFruit and Vegetables - Citrus Processing2007Gravely deficient control system, fraudFLAT RATE25,0 %EUR1 201,240,01 201,24
ITRural Development EAGGF (2000-2006)* - Area related measures2006no cross-checks with the animal database; delayed on-the-spot checksFLAT RATE2,0 %EUR-318 652,00,0-318 652,0
ITRural Development EAGGF (2000-2006)* - Area related measures2006delayed on-the-spot checks; insufficient checks of the use of fertilisersFLAT RATE5,0 %EUR-50 391,00,0-50 391,0
ITRural Development EAGGF (2000-2006)* - Area related measures2006no cross-checks with the animal database; delayed on-the-spot checksFLAT RATE5,0 %EUR-625 923,00,0-625 923,0
ITRural Development EAGGF (2000-2006)* - Area related measures2007no cross-checks with the animal database; delayed on-the-spot checksFLAT RATE5,0 %EUR4 073,00,04 073,0
TOTAL ITEUR-70 255 939,32-2 501 163,36-67 754 775,96
LTCross Compliance2007One GAEC missing, One GAEC badly controlled, Poor definition of severity, claim year 2006FLAT RATE5,0 %EUR26,70,026,7
LTCross Compliance2007Three GAEC missing, Poor definition of severity, claim year 2006FLAT RATE5,0 %EUR-28 566,8-545,96-28 020,84
LTCross Compliance2008One GAEC missing, One GAEC badly controlled, Poor definition of severity, claim year 2007FLAT RATE2,0 %EUR-154 416,570,0-154 416,57
LTCross Compliance2008GAEC not defined (1st pillar only), claim year 2007FLAT RATE5,0 %EUR-404 835,640,0-404 835,64
LTCross Compliance2008One GAEC missing, One GAEC badly controlled, Poor definition of severity, claim year 2006FLAT RATE5,0 %EUR0,830,00,83
LTCross Compliance2008One GAEC missing, One GAEC badly controlled, Poor definition of severity, claim year 2007FLAT RATE5,0 %EUR1 014,70,01 014,7
LTCross Compliance2008Three GAEC missing, Poor definition of severity, claim year 2006FLAT RATE5,0 %EUR-216,86-3,4-213,46
LTCross Compliance2009One GAEC missing, One GAEC badly controlled, Poor definition of severity, claim year 2007FLAT RATE2,0 %EUR-200,950,0-200,95
LTCross Compliance2009One GAEC missing, One GAEC badly controlled, Poor definition of severity, claim year 2008FLAT RATE2,0 %EUR-204 161,540,0-204 161,54
LTCross Compliance2009GAEC not defined (1st pillar only), claim year 2008FLAT RATE5,0 %EUR-468 159,50,0-468 159,5
LTCross Compliance2009One GAEC missing, One GAEC badly controlled, Poor definition of severity, claim year 2006FLAT RATE5,0 %EUR-0,010,0-0,01
LTCross Compliance2009One GAEC missing, One GAEC badly controlled, Poor definition of severity, claim year 2007FLAT RATE5,0 %EUR164,080,0164,08
LTCross Compliance2009One GAEC missing, One GAEC badly controlled, Poor definition of severity, claim year 2008FLAT RATE5,0 %EUR37,580,037,58
LTCross Compliance2009Three GAEC missing, Poor definition of severity, claim year 2006FLAT RATE5,0 %EUR-13,950,0-13,95
LTCross Compliance2010One GAEC missing, One GAEC badly controlled, Poor definition of severity, claim year 2007FLAT RATE2,0 %EUR-24,210,0-24,21
LTCross Compliance2010One GAEC missing, One GAEC badly controlled, Poor definition of severity, claim year 2008FLAT RATE2,0 %EUR-188,770,0-188,77
LTCross Compliance2010One GAEC missing, One GAEC badly controlled, Poor definition of severity, claim year 2006FLAT RATE5,0 %EUR5,410,05,41
LTCross Compliance2010One GAEC missing, One GAEC badly controlled, Poor definition of severity, claim year 2007FLAT RATE5,0 %EUR29,860,029,86
LTCross Compliance2010One GAEC missing, One GAEC badly controlled, Poor definition of severity, claim year 2008FLAT RATE5,0 %EUR29,880,029,88
TOTAL LTEUR-1 259 475,76-549,36-1 258 926,4
MTCross Compliance2008Lenient sanctioning system, claim year 2007FLAT RATE5,0 %EUR-7 853,650,0-7 853,65
MTCross Compliance2009Lenient sanctioning system, claim year 2007FLAT RATE5,0 %EUR-20,610,0-20,61
MTCross Compliance2009Lenient sanctioning system, claim year 2008FLAT RATE5,0 %EUR-13 568,050,0-13 568,05
MTCross Compliance2010Lenient sanctioning system, claim year 2007FLAT RATE5,0 %EUR-2,90,0-2,9
MTCross Compliance2010Lenient sanctioning system, claim year 2008FLAT RATE5,0 %EUR-88,080,0-88,08
MTCross Compliance2010Lenient sanctioning system, claim year 2009FLAT RATE5,0 %EUR-16 838,20,0-16 838,2
MTCross Compliance2010Lenient sanctioning system, claim year 2009FLAT RATE5,0 %EUR142,320,0142,32
MTCross Compliance2011Lenient sanctioning system, claim year 2008FLAT RATE5,0 %EUR-26,860,0-26,86
MTCross Compliance2011Lenient sanctioning system, claim year 2009FLAT RATE5,0 %EUR-26,010,0-26,01
TOTAL MTEUR-38 282,040,0-38 282,04
NLClearance of accounts - Financial Clearance2010known error related to the use of bumble bees for pollinationONE-OFFEUR-688 510,00,0-688 510,0
TOTAL NLEUR-688 510,00,0-688 510,0
PLFruit and Vegetables - Tomato Processing2007weaknesses in the controls checksFLAT RATE5,0 %PLN-1 166 100,45-8 151,74-1 157 948,71
PLFruit and Vegetables - Tomato Processing2007late paymentsONE-OFFPLN-163 034,870,0-163 034,87
PLFruit and Vegetables - Tomato Processing2008weaknesses in the controls checksFLAT RATE5,0 %EUR-340 453,820,0-340 453,82
TOTAL PLPLN-1 329 135,32-8 151,74-1 320 983,58
TOTAL PLEUR-340 453,820,0-340 453,82
ROFinancial audit - Late payments and payment deadlines2011late paymentsONE-OFFEUR-82 812,73-82 812,730,0
TOTAL ROEUR-82 812,73-82 812,730,0
SEFinancial audit - Overshooting2011exceeding of ceilingONE-OFFEUR-3 013,42-3 013,420,0
TOTAL SEEUR-3 013,42-3 013,420,0
SIOther Direct Aid - Ewe and Goats2007Failure to achieve the minimum rate of on-the-spot checks for ovine throughout the retention period and higher level of reductions and exclusions established during on-the-spot checks in the random sample than in the risk analysis sampleFLAT RATE5,0 %EUR-37 036,670,0-37 036,67
SIOther Direct Aid - Article 69 of Reg.1782/2003 - only Ovines and Bovines2008Non application of eligibility sanctions in case of late tagging of calvesONE-OFFEUR-61 130,590,0-61 130,59
SIEntitlements2008Calculation of set-aside entitlements, parcels of land artificially designed in order to fulfil the minimum size requirements, recovery of unduly allocated entitlements and payments, use of national reserve for agricultural land covered by forest, individual casesONE-OFFEUR-25 453,980,0-25 453,98
SIEntitlements2009Calculation of set-aside entitlements, parcels of land artificially designed in order to fulfil the minimum size requirements, recovery of unduly allocated entitlements and payments, use of national reserve for agricultural land covered by forest, individual casesONE-OFFEUR-13 990,920,0-13 990,92
SIEntitlements2010Calculation of set-aside entitlements, parcels of land artificially designed in order to fulfil the minimum size requirements, recovery of unduly allocated entitlements and payments, use of national reserve for agricultural land covered by forest, individual casesONE-OFFEUR-148 484,50,0-148 484,5
TOTAL SIEUR-286 096,660,0-286 096,66
SKFinancial audit - Late payments and payment deadlines2011late paymentsONE-OFFEUR-346 334,22-346 334,220,0
SKCross Compliance2007GAEC not defined, weaknesses in on the spot controls, claim year 2006FLAT RATE5,0 %EUR-398 260,860,0-398 260,86
SKCross Compliance2008GAEC not defined, weaknesses in on the spot controls, claim year 2006FLAT RATE5,0 %EUR-23,840,0-23,84
SKCross Compliance2008GAEC not defined, weaknesses in on the spot controls, claim year 2007FLAT RATE5,0 %EUR-779 668,890,0-779 668,89
SKCross Compliance2009GAEC not defined, weaknesses in on the spot controls, claim year 2006FLAT RATE5,0 %EUR-8,910,0-8,91
SKCross Compliance2009GAEC not defined, weaknesses in on the spot controls, claim year 2007FLAT RATE5,0 %EUR-796,00,0-796,0
TOTAL SKEUR-1 525 092,72-346 334,22-1 178 758,5
6701 TOTALDKK-142 645,00,0-142 645,0
6701 TOTALGBP-1 452 109,170,0-1 452 109,17
6701 TOTALHUF-281 162 836,1-5 622 679,91-275 540 156,19
6701 TOTALPLN-1 329 135,32-8 151,74-1 320 983,58
6701 TOTALEUR-296 785 796,48-18 661 087,63-278 124 708,85
BUDGET ITEM: 6711
BECross Compliance2008GAEC not implemented, partial on the spot controls, claim year 2007FLAT RATE5,0 %EUR-31 470,120,0-31 470,12
BECross Compliance2009GAEC not implemented, partial on the spot controls, claim year 2007FLAT RATE5,0 %EUR-1 440,260,0-1 440,26
BECross Compliance2010GAEC not implemented, partial on the spot controls, claim year 2007FLAT RATE5,0 %EUR-352,150,0-352,15
TOTAL BEEUR-33 262,530,0-33 262,53
BGRural Development EAFRD Axis 2 (2007-2013, area related measures)2009deficiencies in timinig of the on-the-spot checks and sample selectionFLAT RATE2,0 %EUR-40 146,270,0-40 146,27
BGRural Development EAFRD Axis 2 (2007-2013, area related measures)2010deficiencies in timinig of the on-the-spot checks and sample selectionFLAT RATE2,0 %EUR17 174,460,017 174,46
TOTAL BGEUR-22 971,810,0-22 971,81
CYRural Development EAFRD Axis 2 (2007-2013, area related measures)2010Late administrative checks and inappropriate timing of on-the-spot checksFLAT RATE2,0 %EUR-2 062,120,0-2 062,12
CYRural Development EAFRD Axis 2 (2007-2013, area related measures)2011Late administrative checks and inappropriate timing of on-the-spot checksFLAT RATE2,0 %EUR-97 678,930,0-97 678,93
TOTAL CYEUR-99 741,050,0-99 741,05
CZRural Development EAFRD Axis 2 (2007-2013, area related measures)2008Lack of on-the-spot checks on livestock densityFLAT RATE2,0 %EUR-2 153 061,12-10 764,12-2 142 297,0
CZRural Development EAFRD Axis 2 (2007-2013, area related measures)2009Lack of on-the-spot checks on livestock densityFLAT RATE2,0 %EUR-2 321 491,75-11 607,46-2 309 884,29
CZRural Development EAFRD Axis 2 (2007-2013, area related measures)2010Lack of on-the-spot checks on livestock densityFLAT RATE2,0 %EUR-2 418,580,0-2 418,58
CZCross Compliance2008GAEC non defined, Weaknesses in evaluation of non compliances, claim year 2007FLAT RATE5,0 %EUR-621 456,240,0-621 456,24
CZCross Compliance2008GAEC non defined, Weaknesses in evaluation of non compliances, claim year 2008FLAT RATE5,0 %EUR-9,150,0-9,15
CZCross Compliance2009GAEC non defined, Weaknesses in evaluation of non compliances, claim year 2007FLAT RATE5,0 %EUR-10 682,730,0-10 682,73
CZCross Compliance2009GAEC non defined, Weaknesses in evaluation of non compliances, claim year 2008FLAT RATE5,0 %EUR-669 467,880,0-669 467,88
TOTAL CZEUR-5 778 587,45-22 371,58-5 756 215,87
DERural Development EAFRD Axis 1+3 - Investment orientated measures (2007-2013)2007weaknesses in selection among eligible applicationsFLAT RATE10,0 %EUR-130 781,570,0-130 781,57
DERural Development EAFRD Axis 1+3 - Investment orientated measures (2007-2013)2007Payments including ineligible VATONE-OFFEUR-2 698 127,960,0-2 698 127,96
DERural Development EAFRD Axis 1+3 - Investment orientated measures (2007-2013)2008weaknesses in selection among eligible applicationsFLAT RATE10,0 %EUR-105 424,950,0-105 424,95
DERural Development EAFRD Axis 1+3 - Investment orientated measures (2007-2013)2009weaknesses in selection among eligible applicationsFLAT RATE10,0 %EUR-804 414,050,0-804 414,05
TOTAL DEEUR-3 738 748,530,0-3 738 748,53
ESRural Development EAFRD Axis 2 (2007-2013, area related measures)2009Weaknesses on the on-the-spot controls, lack of traceability (claim year 2009 paid in financial year 2009)FLAT RATE2,0 %EUR-90 572,510,0-90 572,51
ESRural Development EAFRD Axis 2 (2007-2013, area related measures)2010Weaknesses on the on-the-spot controls, lack of traceability (claim year 2009 paid in financial year 2010)FLAT RATE2,0 %EUR-126 456,160,0-126 456,16
ESRural Development EAFRD Axis 2 (2007-2013, area related measures)2010Weaknesses on the on-the-spot controls, lack of traceability (claim year 2010 paid in financial year 2010)FLAT RATE2,0 %EUR-125 866,860,0-125 866,86
ESRural Development EAFRD Axis 2 (2007-2013, area related measures)2011Weaknesses on the on-the-spot controls, lack of traceability (claim year 2009 paid in financial year 2011)FLAT RATE2,0 %EUR536,220,0536,22
ESRural Development EAFRD Axis 2 (2007-2013, area related measures)2011Weaknesses on the on-the-spot controls, lack of traceability (claim year 2010 paid in financial year 2011)FLAT RATE2,0 %EUR-36 730,380,0-36 730,38
TOTAL ESEUR-379 089,690,0-379 089,69
FIClearance of accounts - Financial Clearance2009errors detected during the certification exercise for financial year 2009 in EAFRD populationONE-OFFEUR-1 766,40,0-1 766,4
TOTAL FIEUR-1 766,40,0-1 766,4
FRRural Development EAFRD Axis 1 (2007-2013)2007Non-exhaustive administrative control of the preferential loans invoices and late audits in banksFLAT RATE5,0 %EUR-2 678 837,270,0-2 678 837,27
FRRural Development EAFRD Axis 1 - Measures with flat rate support (2007-2013)2008Non-exhaustive administrative control of the preferential loans invoices and late audits in banksFLAT RATE5,0 %EUR-1 015 793,650,0-1 015 793,65
FRRural Development EAFRD Axis 1+3 - Investment orientated measures (2007-2013)2008Non-exhaustive administrative control of the preferential loans invoices and late audits in banksFLAT RATE5,0 %EUR-1 386 514,480,0-1 386 514,48
FRRural Development EAFRD Axis 1+3 - Investment orientated measures (2007-2013)2009Non-exhaustive administrative control of the preferential loans invoices and late audits in banksFLAT RATE5,0 %EUR-125 462,910,0-125 462,91
FRRural Development EAFRD Axis 1 - Measures with flat rate support (2007-2013)2009Non-exhaustive administrative control of the preferential loans invoices and late audits in banksFLAT RATE5,0 %EUR-1 246 558,730,0-1 246 558,73
FRRural Development EAFRD Axis 2 (2007-2013, area related measures)2008deficiencies in the on the spot controlsFLAT RATE5,0 %EUR-21 056 869,750,0-21 056 869,75
FRRural Development EAFRD Axis 2 (2007-2013, area related measures)2009deficiencies in the on the spot controlsFLAT RATE5,0 %EUR-7 898 813,60,0-7 898 813,6
TOTAL FREUR-35 408 850,390,0-35 408 850,39
GBRural Development EAFRD Axis 2 (2007-2013, area related measures)2008weaknesses in LPIS-GIS, in processing of applications, in administrative cross checks, on-the-spot controlsFLAT RATE2,0 %EUR-355 672,24-16 180,58-339 491,66
GBRural Development EAFRD Axis 2 (2007-2013, area related measures)2009weaknesses in LPIS-GIS, in processing of applications, in administrative cross checks, on-the-spot controlsFLAT RATE2,0 %EUR-288 122,530,0-288 122,53
GBRural Development EAFRD Axis 2 (2007-2013, area related measures)2010weaknesses in LPIS-GIS, in processing of applications, in administrative cross checks, on-the-spot controlsFLAT RATE2,0 %EUR-298 761,99-293 852,81-4 909,18
GBRural Development EAFRD Axis 2 (2007-2013, area related measures)2010Weaknesses in LPIS-GIS, on-the-spot checks and payments and sanctionsFLAT RATE5,0 %EUR-1 173 720,590,0-1 173 720,59
GBRural Development EAFRD Axis 2 (2007-2013, area related measures)2008deficiencies in the Agri-environment measuresFLAT RATE2,0 %EUR-3 235 955,12-17 650,45-3 218 304,67
GBRural Development EAFRD Axis 2 (2007-2013, area related measures)2009deficiencies in the Agri-environment measuresFLAT RATE2,0 %EUR-1 117 396,52-4 828,16-1 112 568,36
GBCross Compliance2008Minimum requirements on fertilisers and plant protection and one SMR not adequately controlled, claim year 2008FLAT RATE2,0 %EUR-5 741,430,0-5 741,43
GBCross Compliance2008Lenient sanctioning system, claim year 2007FLAT RATE5,0 %EUR-77 419,70,0-77 419,7
GBCross Compliance2009Minimum requirements on fertilisers and plant protection and one SMR not adequately controlled, claim year 2008FLAT RATE2,0 %EUR-22 884,240,0-22 884,24
GBCross Compliance2009Lenient sanctioning system, claim year 2007FLAT RATE5,0 %EUR32,090,032,09
GBCross Compliance2010Minimum requirements on fertilisers and plant protection and one SMR not adequately controlled, claim year 2008FLAT RATE2,0 %EUR-31,120,0-31,12
GBCross Compliance2010Lenient sanctioning system, claim year 2007FLAT RATE5,0 %EUR-70,690,0-70,69
TOTAL GBEUR-6 575 744,08-332 512,0-6 243 232,08
HUCross Compliance20088 GAEC not defined, claim year 2007FLAT RATE10,0 %EUR-79 998,570,0-79 998,57
HUCross Compliance20098 GAEC not defined, claim year 2007FLAT RATE10,0 %EUR-21 025,020,0-21 025,02
TOTAL HUEUR-101 023,590,0-101 023,59
IEClearance of accounts - Financial Clearance2010Known ErrorONE-OFFEUR-197 620,520,0-197 620,52
IERural Development EAFRD Axis 1 - Measures with flat rate support (2007-2013)2007weaknesses in the verification of declarations made by the agricultural advisors on certain eligibility criteria under the Early Retirement Scheme (measure 113)ONE-OFFEUR-10 122,220,0-10 122,22
IERural Development EAFRD Axis 1 - Measures with flat rate support (2007-2013)2008weaknesses in measurability of objectives in the business plan of the Young Farmers scheme (measure 112)FLAT RATE5,0 %EUR-115 125,00,0-115 125,0
IERural Development EAFRD Axis 1 - Measures with flat rate support (2007-2013)2008weaknesses in the verification of declarations made by the agricultural advisors on certain eligibility criteria under the Early Retirement Scheme (measure 113)ONE-OFFEUR-31 262,80,0-31 262,8
IERural Development EAFRD Axis 1 - Measures with flat rate support (2007-2013)2009weaknesses in measurability of objectives in the business plan of the Young Farmers scheme (measure 112)FLAT RATE5,0 %EUR-134 055,00,0-134 055,0
IERural Development EAFRD Axis 1 - Measures with flat rate support (2007-2013)2009weaknesses in the verification of declarations made by the agricultural advisors on certain eligibility criteria under the Early Retirement Scheme (measure 113)ONE-OFFEUR-20 795,070,0-20 795,07
IERural Development EAFRD Axis 1 - Measures with flat rate support (2007-2013)2010weaknesses in measurability of objectives in the business plan of the Young Farmers scheme (measure 112)FLAT RATE5,0 %EUR-55 436,250,0-55 436,25
IERural Development EAFRD Axis 1 - Measures with flat rate support (2007-2013)2010weaknesses in the verification of declarations made by the agricultural advisors on certain eligibility criteria under the Early Retirement Scheme (measure 113)ONE-OFFEUR-19 051,20,0-19 051,2
IERural Development EAFRD Axis 1 - Measures with flat rate support (2007-2013)2011weaknesses in the verification of declarations made by the agricultural advisors on certain eligibility criteria under the Early Retirement Scheme (measure 113)ONE-OFFEUR-11 113,210,0-11 113,21
TOTAL IEEUR-594 581,270,0-594 581,27
ITAccreditation Paying Agency2008deficiencies in the accreditation criteria for EAFRDFLAT RATE16,0 %EUR-2 885 304,840,0-2 885 304,84
ITAccreditation Paying Agency2009deficiencies in the accreditation criteria for EAFRDFLAT RATE16,0 %EUR-2 709 857,580,0-2 709 857,58
ITAccreditation Paying Agency2009deficiencies in the accreditation criteria for EAFRD (debtors)FLAT RATE16,0 %EUR-4 279,190,0-4 279,19
ITRural Development EAFRD Axis 2 (2007-2013, area related measures)2008delayed on-the-spot checks; insufficient checks of the use of fertilisersFLAT RATE5,0 %EUR-7 886,00,0-7 886,0
ITRural Development EAFRD Axis 2 (2007-2013, area related measures)2008no cross-checks with the animal database; delayed on-the-spot checksFLAT RATE5,0 %EUR-246 930,00,0-246 930,0
TOTAL ITEUR-5 854 257,610,0-5 854 257,61
LTRural Development EAFRD Axis 1 - Measures with flat rate support (2007-2013)2008Weak control system on eligibility of beneficiariesFLAT RATE5,0 %EUR-14 686,920,0-14 686,92
LTRural Development EAFRD Axis 1 - Measures with flat rate support (2007-2013)2009Weak control system on eligibility of beneficiariesFLAT RATE5,0 %EUR-848 148,40,0-848 148,4
LTRural Development EAFRD Axis 1 - Measures with flat rate support (2007-2013)2010Weak control system on eligibility of beneficiariesFLAT RATE5,0 %EUR-766 818,020,0-766 818,02
LTCross Compliance2008One GAEC missing, one GAEC badly controlled, poor definition of severity, claim year 2007FLAT RATE2,0 %EUR-98 669,980,0-98 669,98
LTCross Compliance2009One GAEC missing, one GAEC badly controlled, poor definition of severity, claim year 2007FLAT RATE2,0 %EUR-1 743,380,0-1 743,38
LTCross Compliance2009One GAEC missing, one GAEC badly controlled, poor definition of severity, claim year 2008FLAT RATE2,0 %EUR-101 975,290,0-101 975,29
LTCross Compliance2010One GAEC missing, one GAEC badly controlled, poor definition of severity, claim year 2007FLAT RATE2,0 %EUR392,930,0392,93
LTCross Compliance2010One GAEC missing, one GAEC badly controlled, poor definition of severity, claim year 2008FLAT RATE2,0 %EUR-382,940,0-382,94
TOTAL LTEUR-1 832 032,00,0-1 832 032,0
MTCross Compliance2009Lenient sanctioning system, claim year 2007FLAT RATE5,0 %EUR-6 858,550,0-6 858,55
MTCross Compliance2009Lenient sanctioning system, claim year 2008FLAT RATE5,0 %EUR-8 803,690,0-8 803,69
MTCross Compliance2009Lenient sanctioning system, claim year 2009FLAT RATE5,0 %EUR-33,580,0-33,58
MTCross Compliance2010Lenient sanctioning system, claim year 2007FLAT RATE5,0 %EUR-232,550,0-232,55
MTCross Compliance2010Lenient sanctioning system, claim year 2008FLAT RATE5,0 %EUR-2 078,010,0-2 078,01
MTCross Compliance2010Lenient sanctioning system, claim year 2009FLAT RATE5,0 %EUR-12 545,310,0-12 545,31
MTCross Compliance2011Lenient sanctioning system, claim year 2008FLAT RATE5,0 %EUR-239,50,0-239,5
MTCross Compliance2011Lenient sanctioning system, claim year 2009FLAT RATE5,0 %EUR-53,440,0-53,44
TOTAL MTEUR-30 844,630,0-30 844,63
PLRural Development EAFRD Axis 1 - Measures with flat rate support (2007-2013)2008Weakness in management of the early retirement schemeFLAT RATE2,0 %EUR-253 108,80,0-253 108,8
PLRural Development EAFRD Axis 1 - Measures with flat rate support (2007-2013)2008Weakness in management of the early retirement schemeFLAT RATE5,0 %EUR-9 868 306,450,0-9 868 306,45
PLRural Development EAFRD Axis 1 - Measures with flat rate support (2007-2013)2009Weakness in management of the early retirement schemeFLAT RATE2,0 %EUR-627 971,30,0-627 971,3
PLRural Development EAFRD Axis 1 - Measures with flat rate support (2007-2013)2009Weakness in management of the early retirement schemeFLAT RATE5,0 %EUR-9 761 030,130,0-9 761 030,13
PLRural Development EAFRD Axis 1 - Measures with flat rate support (2007-2013)2010Weakness in management of the early retirement schemeFLAT RATE2,0 %EUR-498 848,260,0-498 848,26
PLRural Development EAFRD Axis 1 - Measures with flat rate support (2007-2013)2010Weakness in management of the early retirement schemeFLAT RATE5,0 %EUR-7 753 973,660,0-7 753 973,66
TOTAL PLEUR-28 763 238,60,0-28 763 238,6
RORural Development EAFRD Axis 1+3 - Investment orientated measures (2007-2013)2009weaknesses in the controls of a risk of creation of artificial conditions, eligibility of the beneficiary, eligibility of expensesFLAT RATE5,0 %EUR-3 579 714,820,0-3 579 714,82
RORural Development EAFRD Axis 1+3 - Investment orientated measures (2007-2013)2010weaknesses in the controls of a risk of creation of artificial conditions, eligibility of the beneficiary, eligibility of expensesFLAT RATE5,0 %EUR-8 921 103,160,0-8 921 103,16
RORural Development EAFRD Axis 2 (2007-2013, area related measures)2009Incomplete checks on parcels and on logbooksFLAT RATE2,0 %EUR-2 239 090,38-2 239 090,380,0
RORural Development EAFRD Axis 2 (2007-2013, area related measures)2010Incomplete checks on parcels and on logbooksFLAT RATE2,0 %EUR-2 959 592,240,0-2 959 592,24
TOTAL ROEUR-17 699 500,6-2 239 090,38-15 460 410,22
SKCross Compliance2008GAEC not defined, on-the-spot checks weaknesses - claim year 2007FLAT RATE5,0 %EUR-378 504,460,0-378 504,46
SKCross Compliance2009GAEC not defined, on-the-spot checks weaknesses - claim year 2007FLAT RATE5,0 %EUR-787,350,0-787,35
TOTAL SKEUR-379 291,810,0-379 291,81
6711 TOTALEUR-107 293 532,04-2 593 973,96-104 699 558,08
BUDGET ITEM: 6500
LTRural Development - Transitional Instrument2007Weak control system on eligibility of beneficiariesFLAT RATE5,0 %EUR-428 809,330,0-428 809,33
LTRural Development - Transitional Instrument2008Weak control system on eligibility of beneficiariesFLAT RATE5,0 %EUR-974 546,180,0-974 546,18
TOTAL LTEUR-1 403 355,510,0-1 403 355,51
PLRural Development - Transitional Instrument2007Weakness in management of the early retirement schemeFLAT RATE5,0 %EUR-4 422 645,430,0-4 422 645,43
PLRural Development - Transitional Instrument2008Weakness in management of the early retirement schemeFLAT RATE5,0 %EUR-1 271 573,680,0-1 271 573,68
PLRural Development - Transitional Instrument2009Weakness in management of the early retirement schemeFLAT RATE5,0 %EUR5 778,150,05 778,15
TOTAL PLEUR-5 688 440,960,0-5 688 440,96
6500 TOTALEUR-7 091 796,470,0-7 091 796,47