Paragraph 5B Objection to and discontinuation of hub and spoke arrangementsF1
At any stage after receipt of a notice under paragraph 5A(5)(a), NHS England may request from C (as defined in paragraph 5A(1)) further information relating to the proposed or commenced hub and spoke arrangements that is relevant to one or more of the objection criteria, and if NHS England makes such a request, C must supply the requested information to NHS England promptly.
For the purposes of this paragraph, the objection criteria are—
the proposed or commenced hub and spoke arrangements do not have the features required by paragraph 5A(7), including where they have had them but they have lapsed;
in the case of commenced hub and spoke arrangements, they have the features required by paragraph 5A(7) but there has been a breach of those requirements;
the proposed hub and spoke arrangements would put, or the commenced hub and spoke arrangements put, the safety of any persons to whom C provides pharmaceutical services at serious risk;
the proposed hub and spoke arrangements would put, or the commenced hub and spoke arrangements put, NHS England at risk of material financial loss;
in the case of commenced hub and spoke arrangements, those arrangements have led to C repeatedly breaching C’s terms of service, or to C breaching its terms of service in circumstances where C is likely to continue to do so repeatedly;
P’s (as defined in paragraph 5A(4)) fitness to carry out core dispensing functions is impaired; or
in the opinion of NHS England, there are reasonable grounds for believing one or more of the objection criteria in paragraphs (a) to (f) are established.
NHS England may, before the commencement of proposed hub and spoke arrangements, issue a notice of objection to the proposed arrangements, based on one or more of the objection criteria and if it does so—
C must not commence the arrangements unless or until the notice of objection is withdrawn by NHS England; and
any arrangements that are commenced, in breach of this sub-paragraph, are invalid.
NHS England may, after the commencement of hub and spoke arrangements, issue a notice of objection to the arrangements, based on one or more of the objection criteria, and if it does so—
those arrangements become invalid; and
C must discontinue the arrangements promptly.
NHS England may withdraw a notice of objection issued under sub-paragraph (4), which has the effect of the arrangements to which the notice related no longer being invalid.
NHS England must, in a notice of objection, give its reasons for issuing the notice.
Subject to sub-paragraph (9), before issuing a notice under sub-paragraph (4), NHS England must make every reasonable effort to communicate and co-operate with C with a view to resolving the matter without the notice being issued.
Where C invites a Local Pharmaceutical Committee to participate in the attempts to resolve the matter referred to in sub-paragraph (7), NHS England must make every reasonable effort to communicate and co-operate with the Committee in its attempts to assist in resolving the matter.
Sub-paragraphs (7) and (8) do not apply where NHS England is satisfied—
its concerns relate to a matter that has already been the subject of dispute resolution between NHS England and C and there are no new issues of substance to delay issuing the notice; or
that it is appropriate to proceed immediately to issuing a notice—
to protect the safety of any persons to whom C may provide pharmaceutical services, or
to protect NHS England from material financial loss.
After issuing a notice of objection under sub-paragraph (3), or issuing a notice of objection under sub-paragraph (4) which was not delayed by virtue of sub-paragraph (7) or (8), NHS England must, where requested to do so by C, make every reasonable effort to communicate and co-operate with C with a view to resolving the matter in a manner that may lead to the notice of objection being withdrawn.
Where C invites a Local Pharmaceutical Committee to participate in the attempts to resolve the matter referred to in sub-paragraph (10), NHS England must make every reasonable effort to communicate and co-operate with the Committee in its attempts to assist in resolving the matter.
Sub-paragraphs (10) and (11) do not apply where NHS England is satisfied its concerns that led to the notice of objection being issued relate to a matter that has already been the subject of dispute resolution between NHS England and there are no new issues of substance to be resolved.